Iowa City Council Overturns Historic Preservation Commission, Approves St. Mary’s Church Demolition Request
The Iowa City City Council voted 6-1 on Tuesday night to reverse a decision by the Historic Preservation Commission, thereby approving St. Mary’s Catholic Church’s request to demolish two buildings in the Jefferson Street Historic District. The buildings, located at 302 and 306 East Jefferson Street, are owned by the church and currently serve as parish offices. St. Mary’s Catholic Church intends to replace these structures with a new ministry center designed to accommodate its growing parish. Although a structural engineer deemed both buildings unsound, the Historic Preservation Commission had denied the demolition request in early October. Approximately 150 people, mostly parishioners, attended the council meeting, with over 20 speaking in favor of demolition, citing the buildings' deterioration and the commission's unrealistic decision. Fr. Andrew Rauenbuehler, the church’s pastor, emphasized the parish’s growth and called the commission’s decision an “excessively absolute interpretation of an undefined...