New York Appellate Division Remands Sokol Syku v American Honda Motor Co., Inc. for In Camera Review of Employment Records
The New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department, has modified an earlier order in the case of Sokol Syku v American Honda Motor Co., Inc. The court remanded the matter for an in camera review to determine the materiality and relevance of the plaintiff's employment records to his claimed injuries. The original order, entered on October 3, 2025, had granted defendants' cross-motion to compel the plaintiff to disclose updated employment records from January 1, 2022, through the present. The plaintiff, Sokol Syku, alleges that a defective tailgate door on his 2017 Honda CR-V caused him serious, permanent injuries requiring multiple surgeries and preventing him from working. While the court found the disclosure of updated employment records to be 'material and necessary' given testimony about the plaintiff's suspension from employment, it also emphasized the need to protect the plaintiff's privacy interests by conducting an in camera review to redact irrelevant or prejudicial information.