Seattle Court of Appeals Reverses Dismissal in Regulatory Takings Case Against City
The Washington State Court of Appeals, Division I, has reversed a trial court's dismissal of a lawsuit filed by GRE Downtowner LLC against the City of Seattle. GRE Downtowner LLC, a developer that invested nearly $40 million in a low-income housing complex, claims that a series of ordinances enacted by the Seattle City Council amounted to a regulatory taking under the Washington State Constitution. These ordinances, implemented from 2018 onwards, included measures such as the Fair Chance Housing Ordinance, the Roommate Ordinance, the Winter Eviction Ban, a COVID-era eviction moratorium, prohibitions on rent increases without 180 days' notice, and requirements for relocation assistance for tenants facing significant rent hikes. GRE alleges that these regulations severely impacted its ability to collect rental income, causing its collection rate to plummet from 93% to 44.1% and leading to millions of dollars in annual losses, thereby interfering with its investment-backed expectations.