Scholarly Publishers Implement Guidelines for Responsible AI Usage in Peer Review Process
Scholarly publishing organizations are increasingly implementing guidelines for the responsible use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in the peer review process. The Annals of Cardiothoracic Surgery, for instance, has updated its guidelines for reviewers, emphasizing the confidential nature of unpublished manuscripts and prohibiting their upload to AI tools that cannot guarantee confidentiality. Reviewers who utilize AI-assisted tools are now required to fully disclose this to the editor, detailing the 'Why, When, Where, What, and How' of their AI usage. This includes the reason for using AI, the timing of its application, specific comments formulated with AI assistance, the name and version of the AI tool, and the process used to ensure privacy and validate AI output. This initiative aims to address the ethical and governance challenges introduced by AI in scholarly publishing while improving efficiency.