California Supreme Court Upholds Partition Sale Amidst Heirs' Dispute Over Deceased Co-Owner's Share
The California Supreme Court, in the 1897 case of Grant v. Murphy, affirmed a judgment that allowed the sale of a San Francisco business building despite an ongoing will contest among the heirs of a deceased co-owner. The court ruled that a co-owner's death and subsequent disputes among heirs do not halt a partition action. The trial court had set the deceased co-owner's share as a whole, leaving the determination of how that share would be split among her children to the probate court. This decision established that the partition court could proceed with the sale, with the proceeds corresponding to the deceased co-owner's share held until the probate court resolved the inheritance dispute. The case involved Adam Grant and Daniel T. Murphy, who owned a San Francisco city lot with a large business building. After Murphy's death, his widow, Anna L. Murphy, inherited a portion. Upon Anna L. Murphy's death, her daughters claimed her share, while other children contested the will, leading to a dispute that was ...