Explore

Bronx Judge Faces Criticism for Sentencing Decisions in High-Profile Cases

Justice Guy Mitchell, a Bronx judge, is under scrutiny for his sentencing decisions in two controversial cases. In 2018, Mitchell sentenced 19-year-old Branlee Gonzalez to nine months in prison for manslaughter and attempted assault, despite initially considering no jail time. Gonzalez had beaten a homeless man to death, and the lenient sentence sparked public outrage. Recently, Mitchell sentenced former NYPD Sgt. Erik Duran to three to nine years in prison for manslaughter after Duran fatally threw a cooler at a fleeing drug suspect, Eric Duprey, in 2023. The judge justified the sentence as a deterrent for police officers, but it has been met with criticism from those who believe Duran was acting to protect others.

Ex-NYPD Sergeant Sentenced for Fatal Incident, Highlighting Complexities of Law Enforcement

Ex-NYPD Sergeant Sentenced for Fatal Incident, Highlighting Complexities of Law Enforcement

Former NYPD Sergeant Erik Duran has been sentenced to 3-to-9 years in prison for manslaughter after fatally injuring Eric Duprey by throwing a cooler at him during a drug sting operation in the Bronx. Duran, who grew up in a violent neighborhood and became a 'model' cop, expressed regret over the incident. The case has drawn attention due to Duran's background and his previous exemplary service record, which included protecting vulnerable individuals and removing firearms from the streets. The incident has sparked discussions about the split-second decisions law enforcement officers must make and the potential consequences of those decisions.

NYC Judge Sentences Ex-NYPD Sergeant to Prison, Aims to Deter Police Misconduct

NYC Judge Sentences Ex-NYPD Sergeant to Prison, Aims to Deter Police Misconduct

A Bronx judge has sentenced former NYPD Sergeant Erik Duran to 3-to-9 years in prison for fatally throwing a picnic cooler at a fleeing drug suspect, Eric Duprey, during an undercover sting operation in August 2023. Judge Guy Mitchell stated that the sentence serves as a 'general deterrent' to other police officers, despite criticism from law enforcement and legal experts who view the punishment as extreme. Duran was found guilty of manslaughter in February, and his legal team, along with many officers, had urged the judge not to impose a prison sentence. The decision has sparked controversy, with some arguing that Duran's actions were a reflex response in a high-pressure situation. The case has drawn attention to the accountability of police officers and the legal system's role in addressing misconduct.

Former NYPD Sergeant Sentenced for Fatal Cooler Incident Involving Moped Rider

Former NYPD Sergeant Sentenced for Fatal Cooler Incident Involving Moped Rider

Former NYPD Sergeant Erik Duran has been sentenced to three to nine years in prison following a fatal incident in which he threw a cooler at Eric Duprey, who was attempting to flee on a moped. The incident resulted in Duprey crashing and subsequently dying from his injuries. Duran, who had a history of commendable service and was inspired to join the police force after the 9/11 attacks, faced a range of public opinions regarding his sentencing. Some advocated for the maximum sentence, while others argued against any jail time. Ultimately, the court decided on a prison term for Duran, marking a significant moment in his career and life.

Ex-NYPD Officer Erik Duran Seeks Release Pending Appeal After Manslaughter Conviction

Ex-NYPD Officer Erik Duran Seeks Release Pending Appeal After Manslaughter Conviction

Erik Duran, a former NYPD officer, is seeking release from custody while appealing his manslaughter conviction. Duran was sentenced to up to nine years in prison for the death of Eric Duprey, whom he struck with a picnic cooler during a 2023 drug sting operation. Duran's legal team argues that the judge's decision was erroneous and not supported by the evidence. Currently held in protective custody at Rikers Island, Duran's lawyers are filing a motion to allow him to be with his family during the appeal process. The appeal will challenge the conviction and the severity of the sentence.

Forest Hills Gardens Corporation Settles Lawsuit with NYC Over Stadium Concerts

Forest Hills Gardens Corporation Settles Lawsuit with NYC Over Stadium Concerts

The Forest Hills Gardens Corporation (FHGC) has reached a $150,000 settlement with New York City over a lawsuit concerning the use of private streets around Forest Hills Stadium during concert events. The lawsuit, filed by the previous FHGC board, claimed that the NYPD unconstitutionally took control of the group's property on concert days to benefit the stadium financially. The settlement was reached after a new board, which campaigned on resolving the lawsuit, took office. The NYPD has agreed to consult with the FHGC board on security arrangements for future events, although they will retain final discretion over safety measures.

Former NYPD officer gets 3 to 9 years in prison for throwing a cooler that caused fatal crash

Former NYPD officer gets 3 to 9 years in prison for throwing a cooler that caused fatal crash

A former New York City police officer has been sentenced to three to nine years in prison for tossing a picnic cooler full of drinks at a fleeing suspect, who then crashed his motorized scooter and died

Former NYPD officer to be sentenced for throwing a cooler that killed a man

Former NYPD officer to be sentenced for throwing a cooler that killed a man

A former New York City police officer is set to be sentenced for tossing a picnic cooler full of drinks at a fleeing suspect, who then crashed his motorized scooter and died

Ex-NYPD Sergeant Sentenced for Fatal Cooler Toss Incident

Ex-NYPD Sergeant Sentenced for Fatal Cooler Toss Incident

Former NYPD Sergeant Erik Duran was sentenced to prison for fatally throwing a cooler at a fleeing drug suspect, Eric Duprey, during a sting operation in the Bronx. Duran, who grew up in a violent neighborhood, was considered a 'model' cop before the incident. He expressed regret for the fatal outcome and highlighted his career dedicated to protecting the vulnerable. Duran's lawyer emphasized his exemplary service, but the court found him guilty of manslaughter. The incident has raised questions about police conduct and accountability.

Former NYPD officer faces sentencing in cooler throwing death

Former NYPD officer faces sentencing in cooler throwing death

A former New York City police officer is set to be sentenced for tossing a picnic cooler full of drinks at a fleeing suspect, who then crashed his motorized scooter and died

Brooklyn Activist Pleads Guilty to Arson of NYPD Vehicles

Brooklyn Activist Pleads Guilty to Arson of NYPD Vehicles

Jakhi McCray, a Brooklyn activist, has pleaded guilty to setting fire to 11 NYPD vehicles last summer. The arson spree, which occurred on June 12, caused $800,000 in damages. McCray admitted to scaling a fence to access a police parking lot in Brooklyn, where he set fire to 10 vehicles and a trailer. He was identified through a cigar lighter and sunglasses left at the scene. McCray, who has a history of arrests at pro-Palestinian protests, faces a mandatory minimum of five years in prison, with a potential sentence of up to 20 years.

Brooklyn activist pleads guilty to setting fire to 11 NYPD vehicles

Brooklyn activist pleads guilty to setting fire to 11 NYPD vehicles

A Brooklyn activist has pleaded guilty to setting fire to 10 empty police vehicles