Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson Challenges Mootness in First Step Act Case at Supreme Court
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson has forcefully pushed back against claims of mootness during oral arguments in the Supreme Court case *Maxwell v. Dinis*. The case concerns whether federal prisoners can use a petition for writ of habeas corpus under Title 28 of the U.S. Code, Section 2241, to challenge the Federal Bureau of Prisons' (BOP) failure to apply First Step Act time credits. These credits, if applied, would allow prisoners to transfer sooner from prison to halfway houses or home confinement. Justice Jackson highlighted that the petitioner, Maxwell, still has several months until his scheduled release, meaning the case is not moot. Furthermore, she argued that even if Maxwell's specific case were to become moot, the underlying issue of improper denial of earned time credits is a recurring problem affecting thousands of individuals annually, necessitating a resolution from the Court rather than a dismissal. The First Step Act, passed during the first Trump administration, aimed to alleviate federal pri...