Explore
Holiday Chronicle
Plymouth vs. Berkeley: Two Thanksgiving Claims That Need Different Definitions
Every year, Americans celebrate Thanksgiving, but was the famous 1621 Plymouth feast really the first? Virginia's Berkeley Plantation has an earlier claim.
Read More
Holiday Chronicle
7 Thanksgiving Myths That Surviving Records Do Not Support
The traditional Thanksgiving story is full of inaccuracies. Here are seven common myths about the Pilgrims and the first Thanksgiving debunked by history.
Read More
Holiday Chronicle
How to Read the 1621 Thanksgiving Account Without Filling In the Gaps
The familiar story of the first Thanksgiving comes from a single paragraph. Here’s how to read it for what it actually says—and what it doesn’t.
Read More
Holiday Chronicle
How to Explain Thanksgiving's Different Origins to a Child Who Wants One Answer
Navigating the complex history of Thanksgiving with kids can be tough. Here’s a guide to explaining the holiday's multiple origin stories honestly.
Read More
Holiday Chronicle
5 Layers to Add to a Thanksgiving History Timeline
The traditional Thanksgiving story is comforting, but incomplete. Here are five historical layers that add crucial context to the holiday's origins.
Read More
Holiday Chronicle
5 Reasons a Single First-Thanksgiving Date Cannot Explain the Whole Holiday
The popular story of the first Thanksgiving in 1621 is only a tiny piece of a much larger, more complex, and contested American history.
Read More
Holiday Chronicle
The Generic "Indian" Costume Never Told Wampanoag Thanksgiving History
The typical Thanksgiving 'Indian' costume misrepresents history. This piece explores what the Wampanoag people actually wore and their true story.
Read More
Holiday Chronicle
Stop Treating a Thanksgiving Painting Like a Photograph From 1621
The famous painting of the 'First Thanksgiving' is iconic, but it's not a historical document. Here's what we know about what really happened in 1621.
Read More
Holiday Chronicle
It Is Normal to Revise the Thanksgiving History You Learned as a Child
The Thanksgiving story most of us learned is more myth than history. Revisiting the facts isn't about cancelling the holiday, but about understanding its true, complex origins.
Read More
Holiday Chronicle
7 Historical Terms That Make Thanksgiving Sources Easier to Read
Unlock the past by learning the historical terms found in Thanksgiving sources, from 'sachem' to 'separatist,' and enrich your understanding of the holiday.
Read More
Holiday Chronicle
You Can Skip the Thanksgiving Origin Skit and Still Teach the History
It's time to retire the inaccurate Pilgrims-and-Indians school pageant. Here's why it's harmful and how to teach a more honest history.
Read More
Holiday Chronicle
The 1623 Day of Thanksgiving Was Not the Famous 1621 Harvest Feast
The Thanksgiving story you know is likely the 1621 harvest feast, but a separate, more religious event in 1623 is key to the holiday's true origins.
Read More