There are some early cues that the new animated “Animal Farm” is not your grandmother's “Animal Farm.” Like when one critter asks, “What's up?” and another says, “Totally rad.” Did George Orwell really have one of his pigs scream, “Check it before you wreck it”?
I don't want to get all prudish here; I'm all for reinventions and reintroductions. But screenwriter Nicholas Stoller and director Andy Serkis' awfully misguided Disneyfication of one of the
greatest allegorical satires in the English language is a cinematic car crash. It's an adaptation for the "PAW Patrol" set made by filmmakers with the movie equivalent of baseball caps worn backward. They should have checked it before they wrecked it.
Stoller hasn’t made just demure alterations to Orwell’s 1940s novella, he’s dragged it through an abattoir, changing small things (a windmill becomes a watermill) to large (a new main character, the piglet Lucky). That whole anti-totalitarian thing that Orwell intended has been given a confusing side-message — a warning about Big Corporatization. (“I want that land. I need that land,” says Freida Pilkington, remade as a venal corporate CEO.)
The self-owns keep coming: An animal field trip to a human mall (“Don't think, just buy it! Buy it all!” the villain pig Napoleon screams), a rom-com grafted for Lucky, a nod to “Midnight Cowboy” ("I'm walkin' here!"), an alcohol-fueled pool party and a nadir when Napoleon — here renamed “NaPoPo” — farts loudly and exclaims: “This is the sound of freedom!”
Here's an “Animal Farm” made modern and cheery, complete with iPhones, sports cars with gull wings, camera-loaded drones, Hazmat suits and digital screens. Instead of an ever-darkening color palette, it's as bright and bouncy as “Daniel Tiger’s Neighborhood,” even though Charles Addams is a better fit than Nickelodeon. There are adorable, giggling piglets. In the book, many are executed. Here they cavort.
An all-star voice cast has been convinced, somehow, to participate, led by Seth Rogen as Napoleon. Initially, that seemed like a total miscast when Rogen leans into his silly, stoner persona, replete with “heh-heh-heh” chuckle. But he later pulls off menace and manipulation surprisingly well. I didn't have Seth Rogen as Stalin on my bingo card for 2026.
“Stranger Things” star Gaten Matarazzo voices plucky Lucky; Laverne Cox is great as NaPoPo's porcine rival, Snowball; Steve Buscemi is a smarmy human employee from the bank; Kieran Culkin is NaPoPo's piggy lieutenant, Squealer; Woody Harrelson tenderly voices the loyal horse Boxer; and Glenn Close is Pilkington, employing some sort of weird, plumby Southern accent. Jim Parsons and Kathleen Turner are in there, too.
As much as you might hold your nose and let the little ones watch to get the essence before they pick up the book in high school, the movie's finale — concocting a "Mission: Impossible"-style revenge caper led by Lucky to right all the wrongs, dubbed “Operation Party Pooper” and ending with an underwater fight scene — is easily the most egregious movie mistake since Johnny Depp was cast in "Sweeney Todd."
Despite the apparent blessing of the Orwell estate, only the barest outlines of the author's story and tone remain — a group of farm animals rebel against their owner and try to create a utopia, only to end up in chains again. But, here, it's like, “Oh, bro, we totally oink-ed it up, no cap.” The movie actually has a hopeful, happy ending, folks — “Animal Farm” remade as cheerful?
Put down Orwell's book and you'll shiver, convinced to redouble your efforts to protect civil society, stand for dignity and fight for the rule of law. Walk out of this new animated movie and you'll likely just want to inhale more M&Ms. And fart.
“Animal Farm,” an Angel Studios release that hits theaters May 1, is rated PG by the Motion Picture Association for thematic elements, some action/violence, rude humor and language. Running time: 94 minutes. Zero stars out of four.
