What is the story about?
The High Court in London has denied Nirav Modi's request to delay his trial related to an unpaid loan from the Bank of India, citing his claims of severe
vision loss and clinical depression. Modi, a fugitive diamond merchant facing extradition to India for a larger fraud case, participated in a pre-trial review via videolink from HMP Pentonville prison, where he argued that his health conditions hindered his ability to prepare for the trial set to begin on March 23.
Court's Ruling
Judge Simon Tinkler determined that Modi would not experience a significant disadvantage during the trial, asserting that he would have equal opportunity to participate in the legal process.Justice Tinkler expressed concern over what he described as a pattern of delay tactics employed by Modi, stating, "Unfortunately, I regard the application that is made as part of a repeated pattern of delay, non-compliance and general muddying of the case by Mr Modi."
Health Concerns Raised
During the proceedings, Modi's barrister, James Kinman, highlighted the difficulties his client faced due to severe vision loss and depression, which he claimed limited Modi's ability to focus and access necessary court documents.Kinman noted that Modi's living conditions in prison, including sharing a cell with a disruptive inmate, have further complicated his situation, emphasizing the need for consideration of these factors in the court's decision.
Response from Bank of India
Tom Beasley, representing the Bank of India, objected to the last-minute application for postponement, arguing that it did not substantively affect Modi's capacity to defend himself.The judge concurred with Beasley, indicating that the application had not been properly notified and warned against future requests that do not demonstrate significant changes in circumstances, labeling such actions as potentially abusive to the court process.
Ongoing Legal Challenges
Modi continues to navigate multiple legal challenges, including an extradition warrant executed in March 2019, which has led to several unsuccessful appeals for bail. He is currently representing himself in the Bank of India trial.In addition to the Bank of India case, Modi faces three sets of criminal proceedings in India, including fraud allegations and charges related to evidence tampering. His extradition case remains pending following the submission of assurances from Indian authorities regarding his treatment upon return.
