What's Happening?
Hawaii's tourism industry is experiencing a significant decline in critical visitor data following the state's transition from paper agricultural declaration forms to the digital Akamai Arrival system. The shift, which began on March 1, 2025, led to the temporary
removal of tourism questions from the mandatory agricultural declaration form. Although these questions were later reinstated, participation in the tourism survey has plummeted. Jennifer Chun, director of tourism research at the Department of Business, Economic Development and Tourism (DBEDT), reported that daily survey responses have fallen from approximately 11,000 paper forms to about 3,800 digital submissions, with only about 1,400 completed in full. This drastic reduction in data has led DBEDT to suspend the publication of visitor figures for Molokai and Lanai due to unreliable estimates. The state remains confident in overall visitor arrival counts and expenditure trends, but detailed visitor characteristics, such as reasons for travel, are now less reliably captured, leading to higher margins of error.
Why It's Important?
The loss of comprehensive visitor data poses a significant challenge for Hawaii's tourism industry, which heavily relies on this information for strategic planning and investment decisions. Tourism agencies, policymakers, and businesses use this data to track visitor behavior, spending habits, demographics, and the effectiveness of marketing efforts. According to Keith Vieira, principal of KV & Associates Hospitality Consulting, this data was a key competitive advantage for Hawaii. Aaron J. Sala, president and CEO of the Hawai‘i Visitors and Convention Bureau, emphasized that reliable data is essential for analyzing traveler behavior, assessing market shifts, and anticipating tourism's impact. Jerry Gibson, president of the Hawai‘i Hotel Alliance, noted that incomplete data can lead to poor decisions regarding hotel renovations, product development, staffing, amenities, and future tourism investments. The impact is particularly severe for smaller islands and local businesses, which depend on precise data to allocate limited marketing resources effectively.
What's Next?
State agencies are actively exploring solutions to increase tourism survey participation and improve data collection. State Sen. Glenn Wakai, a strong advocate for digitizing the agricultural declaration form, acknowledges the concerns but believes the current 23% digital response rate remains statistically meaningful. He proposes 'gamifying' the tourism survey by offering incentives such as coupons, discounts, or promotions from local businesses to encourage completion. This approach aims to both boost response rates and provide targeted marketing opportunities. Keith Vieira supports incentivizing participation but cautions against making the survey mandatory, fearing it could damage goodwill and result in low-quality responses. Jerry Gibson suggests exploring alternative data collection methods, such as gathering information directly from industry sources like airlines and hotels, or hiring a professional firm to aggregate tourism data. These discussions highlight the urgent need for a robust and reliable data collection system to support Hawaii's vital tourism sector.
Beyond the Headlines
The challenges faced by Hawaii in maintaining critical visitor data underscore broader issues related to digital transformation in government and its unintended consequences. While the shift to digital forms aimed to modernize state operations, it inadvertently created a 'permanent gap year in economic time series continuity,' as described by economist Paul Brewbaker. This situation highlights the importance of thorough planning, including running parallel systems during transitions and consulting all relevant stakeholders, to prevent data integrity issues. The debate over mandatory versus incentivized survey participation also touches upon the delicate balance between data collection needs and visitor experience. The long-term implications could include a less competitive tourism market for Hawaii if businesses and policymakers are forced to make decisions based on incomplete or less reliable information, potentially affecting economic stability and resource allocation within the state.













