What's Happening?
Hawaii's transition from paper agricultural declaration forms to the digital Akamai Arrival system has resulted in a significant decline in visitor survey participation, leading to critical gaps in tourism data. The shift, which began on March 1, 2025,
initially removed tourism questions from the mandatory agricultural declaration. Although these questions were later restored to a separate digital survey, participation rates have plummeted. Jennifer Chun, director of tourism research at the Department of Business, Economic Development and Tourism (DBEDT), reported that while 88% of passengers complete the Akamai Arrival declaration, only 23% proceed to the separate tourism survey. This contrasts sharply with the 70% completion rate when the survey was bundled with paper forms. Daily survey responses have fallen from approximately 11,000 paper submissions to about 3,800 digital submissions, with only about 1,400 completed in full. Consequently, DBEDT has suspended visitor statistics for Molokai and Lanai due to unreliable data.
Why It's Important?
The loss of critical visitor data poses a significant threat to Hawaii's tourism industry, which is a cornerstone of the state's economy. Tourism agencies, policymakers, and businesses rely on this information to guide marketing investments, track trends, and plan for future developments. Without accurate and comprehensive data on visitor characteristics, such as reasons for travel or specific demographics, strategic decision-making becomes severely hampered. This can lead to inefficient allocation of resources, misdirected marketing campaigns, and poor investment decisions in areas like hotel renovations and product development. Economist Paul Brewbaker described the disruption as a 'permanent gap year in economic time series continuity,' criticizing the Department of Agriculture & Biosecurity for not adequately consulting tourism stakeholders or running parallel systems during the transition. The impact is particularly severe for smaller islands like Molokai and Lanai, where the lack of data makes it difficult to understand visitor behavior and manage tourism effectively, potentially hindering efforts to balance economic benefits with community well-being.
What's Next?
State agencies are actively exploring solutions to increase tourism survey participation and improve data collection. State Sen. Glenn Wakai, a strong advocate for digitizing state government, acknowledges the concerns but believes the current 23% digital response rate is still statistically meaningful. He proposes incentivizing survey completion through 'gamification,' offering visitors coupons, discounts, or promotions from local businesses. This approach aims to boost response rates while also providing targeted marketing opportunities for Hawaii businesses. Keith Vieira, principal of KV & Associates Hospitality Consulting, supports incentives but cautions against mandatory participation, fearing it could damage goodwill and lead to poor-quality responses. Jerry Gibson, president of the Hawai'i Hotel Alliance, suggests exploring data collection directly from industry sources, similar to hotel-performance reports, or hiring a professional firm to aggregate data from airlines, hotels, and other sources. These discussions highlight a collective effort to restore the reliability and comprehensiveness of Hawaii's visitor data.
Beyond the Headlines
This situation in Hawaii underscores the broader challenges of digital transformation in government and its unintended consequences. While digitization aims for efficiency and modernization, it can inadvertently disrupt established data collection methods and create new vulnerabilities if not implemented with careful consideration of all stakeholders. The reliance on visitor data for economic planning highlights the intricate relationship between technology, policy, and economic stability. The debate over mandatory versus incentivized participation in surveys also touches upon privacy concerns and the balance between data collection needs and visitor experience. Furthermore, the incident reveals the critical importance of inter-agency collaboration and stakeholder consultation during significant systemic changes to avoid 'permanent gaps' in essential data, which can have long-lasting repercussions on policy-making and industry development.













