What's Happening?
Kevin Costner's 1997 post-apocalyptic film, "The Postman," has been included in CBR's recent list of the 10 most unwatchable classic adventure movies. The film, which Costner directed, produced, and starred in, was critically panned and performed poorly
at the box office. Based on David Brin's 1985 novel, the story is set in a United States devastated by an unexplained apocalypse in 2013. Costner portrays a drifter who assumes the identity of a federal mail carrier, offering hope to isolated towns as they confront a warlord, General Bethlehem, played by Will Patton. Despite Costner's previous directorial success with the Oscar-winning "Dances With Wolves" (1990), "The Postman" garnered a 15% score on Rotten Tomatoes and a 29 out of 100 on Metacritic. It also received a B-minus from audiences polled by CinemaScore. The film's domestic box office revenue was approximately $17.6 million against an $80 million budget.
Why It's Important?
The inclusion of "The Postman" on a list of 'most unwatchable' films highlights the significant financial and critical risks associated with large-scale film productions, even for established Hollywood figures like Kevin Costner. The film's substantial budget of $80 million, coupled with its meager $17.6 million domestic gross, represents a considerable financial loss for Warner Bros. and its investors. This outcome underscores the unpredictable nature of audience reception and critical consensus in the entertainment industry. For actors and directors, such a high-profile failure can impact future project funding and career trajectory, demonstrating that past successes do not guarantee future triumphs. The film's enduring negative reputation serves as a cautionary tale regarding creative control and the potential for self-mythologizing projects to alienate both critics and the public.
What's Next?
While "The Postman" is a historical case, its continued presence in discussions about cinematic failures could influence how similar large-budget, director-driven projects are greenlit and marketed in the future. For Kevin Costner, despite this past setback, he has continued to pursue passion projects, such as his more recent directorial effort, "Horizon: An American Saga," which also experienced a challenging opening weekend in 2024. This suggests a continued willingness by some filmmakers to invest in ambitious, personal visions, even in the face of past critical and commercial disappointments. The ongoing re-evaluation of older films by critics and audiences through lists like CBR's ensures that the legacy of such productions, both positive and negative, remains a part of cinematic discourse.
Beyond the Headlines
The narrative surrounding "The Postman" delves into deeper implications concerning artistic vision versus commercial viability in Hollywood. Costner's defense of the film, stating he "always thought it was a really good movie!" and describing it as a "modern-day fairy tale," reveals the subjective nature of artistic evaluation and the potential disconnect between a creator's intent and public perception. The film's sweep of all five categories it was nominated for at the Golden Raspberry Awards—worst picture, worst actor, worst director, worst screenplay, and worst original song—underscores a collective industry and audience rejection. This phenomenon highlights the cultural impact of awards that recognize cinematic failures, shaping public memory and critical discourse around certain films and their creators. It also raises questions about the pressures on artists to deliver both critical acclaim and box office success.













