What's Happening?
The union representing newsroom employees at The Spokesman-Review, the Spokane Editorial Society, has rejected a plan by Comma Community Journalism Lab, the nonprofit poised to take over the newspaper, to retain suspended executive editor Rob Curley in a leadership
role. Curley was suspended in August following allegations of retaliation and ethical breaches. Despite an internal investigation finding no 'harassment or discrimination,' the union expressed strong opposition to Curley's continued involvement, citing his 'challenging' 10-year tenure. Comma's board leadership informed union members that Curley would oversee the philanthropic side of the business and hold a board seat. Union president Thomas Clouse stated that the union would not consider offer letters to work for Comma until they receive written explanations of Curley's new role and their future benefits package. Concerns also extend to the financial stability of Comma and the past financial issues of its co-founder, Scott de Rozic.
Why It's Important?
This situation is critical for the future of local journalism and the integrity of news organizations transitioning to nonprofit models. The union's rejection of Curley's retention highlights significant concerns about leadership, workplace culture, and journalistic independence, especially as the paper aims to become 'The People's Paper' through philanthropy. The controversy could undermine public trust in Comma's ability to operate transparently and ethically, potentially jeopardizing donor support and the long-term viability of the newspaper. The lack of transparency regarding the internal investigation and Curley's exact role creates uncertainty for employees and the community, raising questions about accountability and governance within the new nonprofit structure. This case could set a precedent for how similar transitions are handled in the evolving landscape of local news.
What's Next?
The transfer of ownership of The Spokesman-Review to Comma is scheduled to occur in 10 days, but newsroom employees remain uncertain about their future leadership and employment terms. The union is advocating for Lindsey Treffry, the acting executive editor, to lead the newsroom. Comma's board chair, George Brunt, has disputed the union's description of Curley's new role but has not clarified his exact involvement. The union's refusal to consider offer letters without clear terms indicates potential labor disputes or a mass exodus of staff if their concerns are not addressed. Donors are also pressuring the board for more transparency regarding Comma's finances and the investigation into Curley, suggesting that continued financial support may hinge on a satisfactory resolution. The coming days will likely determine the immediate future of the newspaper's leadership and its transition to a nonprofit model.
Beyond the Headlines
This conflict delves into the complex challenges faced by traditional newspapers attempting to adapt to new economic models, particularly the shift towards nonprofit, community-funded journalism. The core issue extends beyond individual leadership to the fundamental principles of journalistic independence and ethical governance in a donor-supported environment. The union's concerns about potential donor influence on editorial content, as well as the financial background of Comma's co-founder, raise critical questions about the potential for conflicts of interest and the sustainability of such models. This situation highlights the delicate balance required to maintain editorial integrity while relying on philanthropic funding, and it underscores the importance of robust oversight and transparent practices to ensure that the 'people's paper' truly serves the public interest without undue influence.
