What's Happening?
A Woodbury investment firm, Tabone LLC, has filed a lawsuit in U.S. Bankruptcy Court seeking $3 million from the sale of Oheka Castle. The firm alleges that Kahn Property Owner LLC, the castle's owner, and operator Gary Melius, refused to pay for consulting
services. Tabone LLC claims it was hired in early 2024 to help Melius refinance over $60 million in debt. The lawsuit states that Melius dropped Tabone LLC in May 2025 and subsequently refinanced his debt with another company, Taconic Capital. Tabone LLC asserts that Melius had agreed to a $3 million consulting fee regardless of whether the refinancing was completed. The lawsuit was filed as Melius is finalizing a $72 million sale of Oheka Castle to Gold Coast Property & Estate Management LLC. A hearing is scheduled in bankruptcy court to confirm Gold Coast Property & Estate Management's $7.2 million down payment.
Why It's Important?
This lawsuit introduces a significant legal hurdle to the sale of Oheka Castle, a historic Long Island landmark. The outcome could impact the finalization of the $72 million transaction and the distribution of proceeds, potentially delaying the resolution of Melius's substantial debts. For the real estate and hospitality sectors, the case highlights the complexities and potential disputes that can arise in high-value property sales, especially when financial advisory services are involved. The dispute also sheds light on the business dealings surrounding historic properties, where owners often seek external financial expertise to manage significant debt. The legal precedent set by this case could influence how consulting agreements are structured and enforced in future large-scale property transactions.
What's Next?
A hearing is scheduled in bankruptcy court in Central Islip to confirm Gold Coast Property & Estate Management's $7.2 million down payment on Oheka Castle. It remains unclear whether the lawsuit filed by Tabone LLC will impede the sale to Gold Coast. Melius's lawyer, Joseph Maniscalco, has stated that Kahn Property Owner LLC intends to defend its position to disallow Tabone's claim, indicating a contested legal battle ahead. The court will need to determine the validity of Tabone LLC's claim for unpaid consulting fees and whether it has a right to a portion of the sale proceeds. The resolution of this legal dispute will dictate the timeline and final terms of the Oheka Castle sale.
Beyond the Headlines
The lawsuit also reveals details about a previously proposed rebranding of Oheka Castle. Tabone LLC claims that Melius declined a partnership with Four Seasons Hotels & Resorts, which sought naming rights to rebrand the mansion as 'Four Seasons at Oheka Castle.' Melius reportedly rejected this proposal because he 'did not want any partners.' This decision underscores the owner's desire to maintain control over the historic property's identity, even amidst significant financial challenges. The case touches upon the broader tension between preserving the unique character of historic estates and leveraging commercial partnerships for financial stability. The legal proceedings may also bring to light further details about the financial strategies employed in managing such iconic properties.













