What's Happening?
New retail construction has largely ceased due to a combination of rising building costs and increased interest rates, according to insights from the IMN Real Estate Private Funds Summer conference in Newport, Rhode Island. Building costs have surged
approximately 40% since 2022, and interest rates have climbed 100 basis points, while retailer sales per square foot have not kept pace. This makes it uneconomical for new buildings to charge the rent required to cover construction expenses. Additionally, the absence of merchant builders, who previously developed and sold retail centers to investors, has further reduced the flow of new product. National data from CBRE and Cushman & Wakefield confirms this trend, with retail construction completions reaching record lows. For instance, CBRE reported a quarterly low of 5.5 million square feet in Q3 2026, and a four-quarter total of 7.4 million square feet, marking a record low. This scarcity means that nearly all investment returns in retail real estate must now come from existing properties, leading to a highly occupied asset class with a 4.8% availability rate, as per CBRE's Q3 2026 retail report.
Why It's Important?
The halt in new retail construction significantly alters the landscape for retail real estate investors in the U.S. With a national occupancy rate of 96%, the market is characterized by scarcity, which drives up prices and compresses cap rates. This environment means that the traditional target of 16-18% Internal Rates of Return (IRRs) for new retail investors is no longer realistic, with experts like Rob Holuba of CenterSquare Investment Management suggesting returns closer to 12-14%. The shift also means that a substantial portion of returns, often 50-70%, must come from cash flow rather than cap rate compression, as highlighted by Connor O’Brien of Slate Asset Management. This places a greater emphasis on net operating income growth and less on speculative market appreciation. Furthermore, the scarcity of new supply has empowered landlords, giving them more leverage in lease negotiations, particularly with grocery-anchored centers. This dynamic impacts tenants, who are now approaching landlords for early lease renewals to secure space, and investors, who must carefully underwrite each lease and box rather than relying on broad sector trends.
What's Next?
Investors in U.S. retail real estate will need to adjust their strategies to align with the current market realities of low supply and high occupancy. This includes recalibrating return expectations to a more conservative 12-14% IRR and focusing on cash flow generation as the primary driver of returns. Underwriting practices will become more critical, with a need to meticulously evaluate each anchor tenant's rent against market rates, accurately price re-leasing costs, and maintain realistic exit cap rate assumptions. The panel at the IMN conference emphasized the importance of holding exit cap rates flat unless specific market data justifies compression. The increased leverage of landlords suggests that investors should anticipate more demanding lease terms and be prepared for early renewal requests from tenants. The market will likely continue to see strong competition for existing, core-quality retail assets, particularly grocery-anchored properties, which are drawing numerous bids and trading at lower cap rates.
Beyond the Headlines
The current state of U.S. retail real estate investment reflects a broader economic shift where rising construction costs and interest rates are fundamentally reshaping asset valuation and investment strategies. This environment challenges the traditional 'build it and they will come' mentality, forcing a focus on optimizing existing assets. The increased power of landlords and the need for meticulous underwriting could lead to a more professionalized and data-driven approach to retail real estate investment. It also highlights the potential for AI-driven tools, like those offered by Smart Capital Center, to become indispensable for investors to accurately assess deals and manage risk in a complex market. The long-term implication could be a more stable, albeit lower-return, retail real estate sector, where operational expertise and careful financial modeling outweigh speculative growth, potentially leading to a more resilient retail landscape less prone to oversupply cycles.













