What's Happening?
Adam Mazan, President of Risk Placement Services (RPS), is advising retail insurance agents to engage wholesale brokers earlier in the insurance placement process, particularly as the surplus lines market softens. Speaking at the Wholesale & Specialty
Insurance Association's Annual Marketplace, Mazan emphasized that wholesalers should be involved before admitted markets decline coverage or client expectations on price and terms are firmly set. He highlighted that the value of wholesalers lies in their expertise in 'program architecture' and specialized underwriting for complex risks, rather than simply finding capacity. The U.S. surplus lines market recorded a record $143 billion in direct premium in 2025, but its growth has slowed, and AM Best has shifted its outlook for the segment from positive to stable.
Why It's Important?
The shift in the surplus lines market from a hard market to a more competitive, softening environment significantly impacts U.S. businesses seeking specialized insurance coverage. Retailers who delay involving wholesale brokers risk clients having unrealistic expectations, potentially leading to less favorable terms or even coverage gaps. Early engagement with wholesalers, who possess expertise in complex, hard-to-model exposures like catastrophe-exposed property and environmental liability, can ensure businesses secure appropriate and cost-effective coverage. This strategic approach is crucial for industries facing unique risks, as it helps manage expectations and leverages specialized knowledge to navigate a changing insurance landscape, ultimately protecting their assets and operations.
What's Next?
As the surplus lines market continues to soften, the role of wholesale brokers will increasingly be judged on the expertise and strategic value they bring to the table. Retail agents are expected to face growing pressure to demonstrate their value beyond simply placing policies, necessitating a deeper collaboration with wholesale partners. The industry will likely see a continued emphasis on specialized underwriting and 'program architecture' to address complex risks. This trend suggests that wholesale brokers who can offer sophisticated solutions and proactive engagement will gain a competitive advantage, while those who merely provide capacity after admitted market rejections may struggle to maintain relevance.
Beyond the Headlines
The evolving dynamics in the surplus lines market underscore a broader shift in the insurance industry towards greater specialization and advisory roles. The emphasis on 'program architecture' and specialized underwriting highlights the increasing complexity of risks faced by modern businesses, from climate-related events to emerging liabilities. This trend could lead to a more sophisticated insurance ecosystem where expertise and strategic partnerships are paramount. It also suggests a potential for increased scrutiny on the value proposition of all intermediaries in the insurance chain, pushing for greater transparency and demonstrable benefits for policyholders. The long-term implication is a more tailored and potentially more resilient insurance market, but one that demands higher levels of expertise and collaboration.













