What's Happening?
Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff recently announced on X that Search Engine Optimization (SEO) is no longer relevant, asserting that customers are now using AI assistants like Claude, ChatGPT, and Gemini to find brands, bypassing traditional search engines.
Benioff promoted Palmata, an AI-based tool designed to track a company's visibility in AI answers, monitor what AI assistants say about a business, offer recommendations for changes, and simulate the effects of those changes. This declaration comes despite Salesforce's own guide, published on September 11 by SEO Senior Director Graham Hardt, which states that SEO 'isn’t going away' and 'is still the foundation.' Palmata, introduced by Contentful in June, became part of Salesforce following its acquisition of Contentful on September 1. Jason McGhee, head of product and engineering for Palmata, also previously stated that SEO provides a 'practical framework for improving visibility' and that 'That work remains essential.' Several SEO professionals have countered Benioff's claims, emphasizing that AI search still relies on many of the same fundamentals as SEO.
Why It's Important?
Marc Benioff's statement carries significant weight within the business and marketing communities due to his prominent role as CEO of Salesforce, a leading cloud-based software company. His assertion that SEO is dead could influence marketing executives and businesses to shift their strategies and investments away from traditional SEO practices towards AI visibility tools like Palmata. This could lead to a reallocation of marketing budgets and a re-evaluation of digital marketing priorities across various industries. However, the contradiction between Benioff's public stance and Salesforce's internal guidance creates confusion and potential distrust among businesses seeking clear direction in the evolving digital landscape. For SEO professionals, this presents both a challenge to defend the continued relevance of their field and an opportunity to highlight the foundational role of SEO in supporting AI visibility. Businesses that prematurely abandon SEO based on such pronouncements might lose organic search visibility, while those that integrate both SEO and AI visibility strategies may gain a competitive advantage.
What's Next?
The immediate future will likely see continued debate within the digital marketing industry regarding the interplay between traditional SEO and AI-driven visibility. Marketing executives will need to carefully evaluate their strategies, potentially seeking to integrate tools like Palmata while not entirely abandoning established SEO practices. Salesforce's guide recommends tracking both organic traffic and rankings (SEO metrics) as well as how often a brand is cited by AI (AI visibility metrics). This suggests a dual approach rather than a complete pivot. SEO professionals are expected to continue advocating for the foundational importance of SEO, emphasizing that AI search optimization often builds upon existing SEO principles. The market for AI visibility tools is also likely to grow, with more companies developing solutions to help brands monitor and optimize their presence in AI assistant responses. Businesses will need to adapt to these evolving dynamics, potentially investing in training for their marketing teams to understand and implement both SEO and AI visibility strategies effectively.
Beyond the Headlines
This development highlights a broader shift in how information is consumed and discovered, moving from traditional search queries to conversational AI interactions. The underlying implication is a potential redefinition of 'discoverability' for businesses, where direct brand mentions by AI assistants become as crucial, if not more so, than organic search rankings. This shift could lead to new ethical considerations regarding how AI assistants source and present information, and the potential for bias or manipulation in AI-generated recommendations. Furthermore, it raises questions about data analytics and attribution, as Benioff noted, 'No click. No referral. Nothing in your analytics,' which could complicate how businesses measure the effectiveness of their digital presence. The long-term impact could be a more integrated approach to digital marketing where content creation, technical SEO, and AI optimization are inextricably linked, requiring a more holistic and adaptive strategy from businesses to maintain visibility and relevance in an AI-first digital ecosystem.













