What's Happening?
Wes Moss, a certified financial planner and chief investment strategist at Capital Investment Advisors, recently explained how the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) assesses financial need, particularly for families with substantial assets.
During an episode of The Clark Howard Podcast, Moss highlighted that certain assets, such as grandparent-owned 529 plans, home equity, 401(k)s, IRAs, and Roth accounts, are not counted in the FAFSA's calculation of the Student Aid Index (SAI). He provided an example of a family earning $250,000 annually with $1 million in a 401(k) who would receive no need-based aid for a $50,000-a-year school, primarily due to their income and other countable assets like brokerage accounts. Moss emphasized that the type of account holding savings significantly impacts financial aid eligibility, with brokerage accounts being counted while retirement accounts are not. He also warned about the timing of capital gains, noting that gains realized two years prior to the FAFSA application can substantially increase the SAI, similar to how Medicare's IRMAA surcharges operate.
Why It's Important?
Moss's insights are crucial for U.S. families planning for college expenses, especially those with higher incomes and significant savings. Understanding which assets are considered by FAFSA and which are excluded can dramatically alter a family's eligibility for financial aid. The distinction between assets held in retirement accounts versus brokerage accounts, for instance, can mean the difference between receiving aid and being deemed ineligible. This information empowers families to strategically manage their finances to potentially maximize their aid opportunities. For instance, keeping 529 plans under a grandparent's name can prevent them from being counted as parental assets. The timing of capital gains is another critical factor, as a large gain in the 'base year' can inflate a family's SAI, leading to reduced or eliminated aid. This knowledge is particularly valuable for financial advisors and parents navigating the complex landscape of college funding, as it directly impacts the financial burden of higher education.
What's Next?
Families preparing for college applications should review their financial strategies in light of Moss's advice. Key actions include identifying the FAFSA's 'base year' for income and assets to strategically time any significant financial transactions, such as realizing capital gains. For a fall 2028 freshman, the FAFSA will use 2026 tax data, making any gains booked before December 31, 2026, relevant. Families should also consider having grandparents retain ownership of 529 plans to exclude them from FAFSA calculations. Additionally, Moss suggests utilizing state deductions for 529 contributions, even if the funds are quickly withdrawn for tuition. He advises using the Federal Student Aid calculator at StudentAid.gov to estimate their SAI and understand the potential impact of various financial scenarios. These proactive steps can help families optimize their financial aid eligibility and better plan for college costs.
Beyond the Headlines
The detailed breakdown of FAFSA calculations by Wes Moss highlights a broader issue within the U.S. higher education financing system: the complexity and often counterintuitive nature of financial aid eligibility. While designed to assist families, the FAFSA's rules can inadvertently penalize those who have diligently saved, particularly if their savings are held in certain types of accounts or if they experience significant income fluctuations. This situation can lead to a perception of unfairness, where families with substantial assets, but not necessarily high liquid income, are expected to bear the full cost of education. The emphasis on account type rather than overall wealth can also encourage financial maneuvering, potentially diverting funds from more accessible savings vehicles to those excluded by FAFSA. This dynamic underscores the ongoing debate about equitable access to higher education and the need for clearer, more transparent financial aid policies that genuinely reflect a family's capacity to pay.













