What's Happening?
Hailey Bieber's beauty brand, Rhode, achieved approximately $390 million in net sales in fiscal year 2026, marking an 80% year-over-year increase. It has become the number-one brand at Sephora in both the U.S. and the U.K. and was acquired by e.l.f. for
up to a billion dollars. Despite this significant success, a recent interview with Andrew Ross Sorkin at the DealBook Summit saw Bieber attribute part of her brand's growth to 'delusion.' This comment led to public criticism, with many suggesting she lacked business literacy or a clear understanding of her company's operations. The brand's ability to consistently sell out products within days of launch and its high repeat-purchase rates, as noted by e.l.f.'s CEO, indicate a strong market presence and customer loyalty. The discussion highlights a perceived disconnect between traditional business explanations and the actual drivers of success for certain celebrity-founded brands.
Why It's Important?
This situation is important because it challenges conventional notions of business acumen and strategic communication within the U.S. beauty and consumer goods industries. The public's reaction to Hailey Bieber's 'delusion' comment underscores a societal expectation for founders, especially those in high-profile positions, to articulate their success using established business jargon. However, Rhode's financial performance suggests that effective strategy might not always conform to easily quantifiable or explainable metrics. This could influence how investors, marketers, and other entrepreneurs evaluate success, potentially shifting focus from purely analytical frameworks to a greater appreciation for intangible factors like brand 'soul' or intuitive market understanding. It also highlights a potential double standard, where female founders, particularly celebrities, face intense scrutiny regarding their business knowledge, regardless of their companies' financial achievements. The debate could lead to a re-evaluation of what constitutes 'business literacy' in an evolving market driven by influence and perception.
What's Next?
The ongoing discussion surrounding Hailey Bieber's approach to her brand's success may prompt further examination of how celebrity-founded businesses are perceived and analyzed. Industry analysts and business commentators are likely to continue dissecting Rhode's growth trajectory to identify the underlying, perhaps 'illegible,' strategies that contributed to its rapid expansion. This could lead to new frameworks for understanding success in the influencer-driven economy, moving beyond traditional metrics to include factors like authentic connection and perceived effortlessness. Other celebrity entrepreneurs might adjust their public communication strategies, either by embracing more conventional business language or by leaning into the 'mystery' of their success. The incident could also encourage a broader conversation within business education and media about the diverse paths to entrepreneurial achievement and the limitations of applying a single standard of 'business literacy' to all founders.
Beyond the Headlines
The deeper implications of this event touch upon the ethical and cultural dimensions of entrepreneurship in the digital age. The public's demand for a 'recipe' for success, particularly from female founders, raises questions about intellectual property and the pressure to reveal proprietary strategies. The idea that some successful strategies are 'illegible' or cannot be easily replicated suggests a shift in competitive advantage, where unique intuition and brand identity become more valuable than easily copied business models. This could lead to a re-evaluation of what constitutes a 'moat' in business, moving from tangible assets or processes to intangible elements like brand perception and emotional connection. Furthermore, the double standard applied to female founders, where both overt business-speak and a lack thereof can draw criticism, highlights persistent gender biases in how entrepreneurial success is judged and communicated. This incident encourages a more nuanced understanding of how successful brands are built and sustained, acknowledging that not all genius can be neatly packaged into bullet points.













