What's Happening?
A new report from Bain & Company, titled 'AI Is the New Search. Here’s How Retailers Win the Answer,' indicates that artificial intelligence (AI) is fundamentally altering the retail shopping landscape. The report highlights that traditional market share
no longer assures a retailer's visibility in AI-driven shopping recommendations. Bain's analysis, which involved over 4,400 shopping prompts and 300,000 unique runs across leading large language models (LLMs), reveals that category specialists often outperform general retailers in AI answers relative to their market share. Approximately one-third of U.S. consumers now utilize AI assistants during their shopping journeys, a significant increase from 19% in 2025. Retailers are now competing on three fronts: third-party (3P) assistants, first-party (1P) assistants, and customers’ personal AI agents. While AI referral traffic is currently less than 1% of overall web traffic, it converts 90% better than non-AI traffic, underscoring its growing influence on consumer decision-making.
Why It's Important?
This shift is critical for U.S. retailers as AI assistants increasingly influence consumer purchasing decisions, even if they don't complete the final transaction. Retailers who fail to adapt to this new AI-driven search paradigm risk losing traffic, brand awareness, and ultimately, profits. The report emphasizes that building trust with consumers through AI is paramount; retailer-led AI assistants are trusted nearly twice as much as third-party assistants (21% vs. 12%). Despite this, only 27 of the 100 largest U.S. retailers currently operate their own 1P assistants. Retailers relying solely on 3P assistants risk ceding the primary customer relationship and valuable proprietary data, which are difficult to reclaim. This dynamic creates a competitive advantage for retailers who proactively develop robust AI strategies, including optimizing for generative engine optimization (GEO) and investing in their own AI assistants.
What's Next?
Bain & Company advises retailers to implement a year-end checklist to navigate this evolving landscape. Key actions include conducting prompt audits to assess 3P visibility for crucial items and occasions, closing GEO gaps to ensure their value proposition is clear to AI bots, and updating important web pages with customer-centric language. Retailers are also urged to review their 1P assistant roadmaps, with a recommendation to consider white-label or outsourced solutions for faster deployment if an early 2027 launch plan isn't in place. Furthermore, preparing consumer and product data for hyper-personalization within 1P assistants and defining an agent-to-agent strategy are crucial next steps. These measures are designed to help retailers secure a competitive edge during the holiday shopping season and beyond, as AI's role in retail continues to expand.
Beyond the Headlines
The rise of AI in retail shopping presents deeper implications beyond immediate sales figures. It signals a fundamental shift in how brands connect with consumers, moving from traditional search engine optimization to 'generative engine optimization.' This transition demands that retailers not only understand algorithms but also how AI interprets and presents information, emphasizing clarity and specificity in their value propositions. The increasing reliance on AI assistants also raises questions about data privacy and the ethical use of consumer data for hyper-personalization. Retailers that successfully integrate AI will gain not just market share but also invaluable insights into consumer behavior, potentially leading to more personalized shopping experiences and stronger customer loyalty. Conversely, those who lag could face significant challenges in maintaining relevance in an increasingly AI-mediated marketplace, highlighting a growing digital divide among retailers.













