What's Happening?
MSCI, a financial services company, announced on November 11 that it will remove Strategy (MSTR), a software company that has become a significant Bitcoin treasury holder, from the MSCI USA Index at the close of November 30. Japan-based Bitcoin treasury company Metaplanet
(MTPLF) will also be removed. Additionally, Ethereum treasury company SharpLink (SBET) has been placed on a public watch list. This decision follows a year-long dispute, where MSCI initially proposed excluding companies with 50% or more of their total assets in digital assets in October 2025. After objections from over 250 organizations, this proposal was dropped in January. However, in August, MSCI introduced a broader screening method targeting 'non-operating companies' based on five financial-ratio flags. Strategy criticized this new screening method as 'pretextual,' suggesting it was designed to specifically target Bitcoin treasury companies, noting that Strategy alone accounts for approximately 87% of the market value affected by these exclusions.
Why It's Important?
The removal of Strategy and Metaplanet from MSCI's indexes carries significant implications for companies holding substantial digital assets. Index funds that track MSCI benchmarks will be compelled to sell their shares in Strategy and Metaplanet by the end of November, potentially leading to increased selling pressure on these stocks. While some of this selling may have been anticipated after the August proposal, forced selling can create market volatility. More broadly, this action sets a precedent for other index providers, such as the S&P Dow Jones Indices group. Although these other providers have not yet adopted similar screening criteria, MSCI's template could be emulated, potentially affecting more crypto treasury stocks in the future. This development highlights a growing scrutiny of companies whose business models heavily rely on a single digital asset, challenging the assumption that passive investing will always support such entities.
What's Next?
Index funds tracking MSCI benchmarks are expected to divest their holdings in Strategy and Metaplanet by the November 30 deadline, which could lead to further downward pressure on the stock prices of these companies. Strategy held an investor call on November 19, where Executive Chairman Michael Saylor and CEO Phong Le discussed preferred stock, credit markets, and Bitcoin-per-share metrics, but notably did not address the MSCI index removal. This silence suggests the company may be navigating the implications internally or choosing not to publicly engage with the decision. The market will be watching to see if other major index providers adopt similar screening methodologies, which could broaden the impact on other companies with significant digital asset treasuries. Strategy's current trading at a discount to its Bitcoin holdings, coupled with the loss of index support, indicates a need for the company to re-evaluate its strategy to regain investor confidence and its 'mNAV premium.'
Beyond the Headlines
The decision by MSCI to remove Strategy and Metaplanet from its indexes raises fundamental questions about how traditional financial institutions categorize and value companies with significant digital asset holdings. Strategy's assertion that its Bitcoin business is an operating segment, a stance it claims was discussed with SEC staff, underscores a broader debate about the classification of crypto-centric business models. The 'pretextual' argument by Strategy suggests a potential tension between established financial indexing rules and the evolving nature of corporate treasuries in the digital age. This situation could prompt a re-evaluation of how index providers define 'operating companies' and manage risk associated with highly concentrated digital asset portfolios. It also highlights the ethical considerations when new rules disproportionately affect a small number of entities, particularly when those entities represent a significant portion of a nascent market segment. The long-term implications could include a clearer regulatory framework for companies holding digital assets and a more defined approach from financial indexes regarding their inclusion criteria.













