What's Happening?
The Eversheds Sutherland SALT Scoreboard for the third quarter of 2026 indicates that taxpayers achieved favorable outcomes in 17 out of 35 significant state tax cases across the United States. This report, which has been tracking taxpayer wins and losses
in state tax cases since 2016, provides insights into key judicial decisions and emerging trends in state and local taxation. The latest edition specifically examines developments related to manufacturing exemptions, addbacks, and the taxability of prewritten computer software. A particular focus of this quarter's analysis was on cases involving Public Law 86-272, a federal law that limits states' ability to tax income from interstate commerce.
Why It's Important?
This report offers crucial insights for businesses and tax professionals navigating the complex landscape of state and local tax (SALT) laws. The nearly 50% success rate for taxpayers in significant cases suggests that businesses are effectively challenging state tax assessments, potentially leading to substantial tax savings or refunds. Understanding the trends highlighted in the Scoreboard, such as those concerning manufacturing exemptions and software taxability, can inform corporate tax strategies and compliance efforts. The focus on Public Law 86-272 is particularly significant as it impacts how states can tax out-of-state businesses, influencing nexus rules and apportionment methodologies. These outcomes can shape future state tax legislation and judicial interpretations, affecting businesses operating across state lines.
What's Next?
Businesses and tax practitioners will likely analyze the detailed findings of the Eversheds Sutherland SALT Scoreboard to refine their tax planning and litigation strategies. The trends identified in this report could influence how companies structure their operations, particularly regarding manufacturing activities and software sales, to optimize their state tax liabilities. State tax authorities may also review these judicial outcomes to assess the effectiveness of their current tax laws and enforcement practices, potentially leading to legislative adjustments or changes in audit approaches. The ongoing interpretation of Public Law 86-272 will continue to be a critical area, with future court decisions further clarifying its scope and application in the evolving digital economy.
Beyond the Headlines
The consistent tracking of state tax case outcomes by reports like the SALT Scoreboard highlights the dynamic and often contentious relationship between taxpayers and state governments. The prevalence of litigation in these areas underscores the ambiguities and complexities inherent in state tax codes, which often struggle to keep pace with modern business models and technological advancements. The outcomes of these cases can have far-reaching implications, influencing not only individual companies but also broader economic development strategies as states compete to attract and retain businesses. Furthermore, the ongoing legal battles over issues like software taxability reflect fundamental debates about how to fairly and effectively tax digital goods and services in an increasingly digital economy, shaping the future of state revenue generation.













