What's Happening?
DoorDash has released data from its 2025 Thanksgiving ordering, revealing unexpected trends in dessert and side dish popularity across the United States. Contrary to popular belief, chocolate cake emerged as the most ordered store-bought pie or cake nationally
during Thanksgiving week, surpassing traditional favorites. Apple pie ranked second, followed by cheesecake, with pumpkin pie, often considered the quintessential Thanksgiving dessert, placing fourth. Pound cake rounded out the top five. The analysis also highlighted distinct regional preferences, with DoorDash identifying which desserts and sides each state ordered at a higher rate than the national average. For instance, while pumpkin pie was strong in 14 states, including California and Washington, Hawaii ordered it at nearly three times the national share. Mashed potatoes led the national side dish rankings, followed by corn and sweet potatoes, but regional variations were significant, such as cornbread in Texas and mac and cheese in North Carolina.
Why It's Important?
This DoorDash report offers valuable insights into evolving consumer preferences and regional culinary identities within the U.S., particularly during a major holiday like Thanksgiving. For food businesses and retailers, understanding these trends can inform inventory management, marketing strategies, and product development, allowing them to better cater to local tastes. The data challenges long-held assumptions about traditional holiday foods, suggesting a diversification of palates and a growing acceptance of non-traditional options. This shift could influence food manufacturers to innovate and offer a wider range of holiday-themed products. For the restaurant and catering industry, these insights can help tailor menus and promotions to specific state-level demands, potentially boosting sales during peak holiday seasons. The findings also underscore the role of delivery platforms like DoorDash in capturing and reflecting real-time consumer behavior, providing a dynamic snapshot of American dining habits.
What's Next?
As Thanksgiving 2026 approaches, food retailers, restaurants, and delivery services will likely leverage these insights to prepare their holiday offerings. We can anticipate marketing campaigns that highlight popular regional desserts and sides, and potentially new product introductions that cater to the identified preferences, such as more diverse cake options alongside traditional pies. DoorDash and similar platforms may continue to analyze and publish such data, further influencing consumer trends and business strategies in the food sector. This ongoing data collection will provide a continuous feedback loop, allowing businesses to adapt quickly to changing tastes. The findings might also spark discussions among consumers about their own Thanksgiving traditions and preferences, potentially leading to more varied holiday menus in homes across the country. Future reports could delve deeper into the reasons behind these preferences, such as demographic shifts or cultural influences.
Beyond the Headlines
The DoorDash Thanksgiving data subtly reflects broader cultural shifts in American society, including increased culinary diversity and the impact of convenience on food choices. The rise of chocolate cake over pumpkin pie, for example, might indicate a generational shift in preferences or the influence of broader dessert trends. The reliance on delivery services for holiday meals also points to changing lifestyles, where convenience and time-saving options are increasingly valued, even for traditional events. This trend could have long-term implications for home cooking traditions and the role of prepared foods in holiday celebrations. Furthermore, the detailed state-by-state breakdown highlights the enduring strength of regional identities within the U.S., even in an increasingly globalized and interconnected world. It suggests that while national trends exist, local tastes remain a powerful force shaping consumer behavior, offering a rich tapestry of American culinary heritage.













