What's Happening?
On October 28, 2026, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) officially rescinded its 2012 "Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment Decisions Under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964."
This guidance previously advised employers on how to avoid discrimination claims when using criminal history information in hiring. The 2012 guidance identified two types of discrimination: disparate impact, where a neutral policy disproportionately affects protected classes, and disparate treatment, involving intentional discrimination. It recommended best practices such as not asking about convictions on job applications and limiting inquiries to job-related offenses. Despite the rescission, employers are not required to alter existing lawful practices, and the fundamental federal, state, and local laws, including Title VII's prohibition against disparate impact, remain in full effect. EEOC Chair Andrea Lucas emphasized that this action does not grant employers permission to engage in unlawful discrimination.
Why It's Important?
The EEOC's rescission of its 2012 guidance on criminal records in employment decisions carries significant implications for U.S. employers and job seekers. While the guidance itself is no longer active, the underlying federal, state, and local anti-discrimination laws, particularly Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, remain fully enforceable. This means employers still bear the responsibility to ensure their hiring practices do not result in disparate impact or disparate treatment based on race or national origin, even when considering criminal histories. The move could lead to increased scrutiny of employer background check policies, as the EEOC has affirmed its commitment to vigorously enforce existing protections. Employers who might interpret the rescission as a green light for more expansive criminal record screening without careful consideration of its discriminatory potential could face legal challenges. Conversely, job applicants with past criminal records may find their employment prospects still subject to the same legal protections against discriminatory practices, despite the change in EEOC guidance.
What's Next?
Following the rescission, employers are advised to proceed cautiously and avoid immediate changes to their hiring policies concerning arrest and conviction records. Legal experts recommend that employers thoroughly review all applicable state and local laws before making any revisions to their criminal record screening practices. States like California, New York, and Illinois, for instance, have specific prohibitions regarding the use of arrest or conviction records in employment decisions, which remain unaffected by the EEOC's action. The EEOC has made it clear that it will continue to enforce Title VII protections against discrimination, including practices that act as proxies for intentional discrimination. Therefore, employers should anticipate ongoing oversight and potential enforcement actions if their policies are found to have a discriminatory effect, regardless of the absence of the 2012 guidance. The focus will likely shift to the direct application of Title VII and other relevant statutes in assessing the legality of background check procedures.
Beyond the Headlines
The rescission of the EEOC's 2012 guidance highlights a nuanced shift in regulatory approach rather than a fundamental change in anti-discrimination law. It underscores the ongoing tension between employers' needs for security and risk management and the societal goal of providing fair employment opportunities, particularly for individuals with past criminal records. The original guidance aimed to reduce barriers to employment for minority groups disproportionately affected by the criminal justice system. While the guidance is gone, the underlying ethical and legal considerations of second-chance employment remain. This development could prompt a re-evaluation of corporate social responsibility initiatives related to hiring practices and potentially lead to new legislative efforts at the state or federal level to clarify or strengthen protections for job applicants with criminal histories. The long-term impact will depend on how employers adapt their practices and how vigorously the EEOC and other enforcement bodies interpret and apply existing anti-discrimination laws.













