What's Happening?
Acima Digital, LLC and Acima Holdings, LLC (collectively, Acima), rent-to-own companies, have reached a settlement in a multistate investigation led by 43 State Attorneys General (AGs). The settlement, announced on November 12, resolves allegations regarding
Acima’s rental-purchase agreements (RPAs) without an admission of liability or wrongdoing by the company. The agreement includes $183.5 million in monetary relief, comprising $43 million in consumer restitution, $10.5 million for participating AGs, and $130 million in lease forgiveness. Acima will also cover up to $700,000 in settlement administration costs. The investigation alleged that Acima engaged in practices such as marking up cash prices, presenting misleading electronic disclosures, obstructing consumers' ability to terminate agreements, furnishing inaccurate information to credit reporting agencies, and employing deceptive servicing and collection practices. The settlement imposes extensive injunctive requirements on Acima's advertising, disclosure, servicing, and reporting of RPAs, as well as its oversight of retail partners.
Why It's Important?
This settlement is significant for consumer protection, particularly for individuals utilizing rent-to-own agreements. The $183.5 million in monetary relief, including substantial consumer restitution and lease forgiveness, directly benefits consumers who may have been subjected to alleged deceptive practices. The injunctive terms are designed to ensure greater transparency and fairness in Acima's operations. For instance, Acima is now prohibited from advertising that consumers will pay only the cash price or implying that RPAs are loans or credit. It must also prominently disclose the total cost of an RPA and ensure that the cash price disclosed is not marked up above the retailer's price. These changes aim to prevent consumers from being misled about the true cost and nature of their agreements. The settlement also addresses credit reporting inaccuracies and deceptive collection practices, which can have long-term financial consequences for consumers. The involvement of 43 State Attorneys General underscores a broad, coordinated effort to regulate rent-to-own industries and protect vulnerable consumers.
What's Next?
Acima generally has 60 days to implement the extensive conduct requirements outlined in the settlement, with some provisions allowing for longer transition periods. Key changes include revised advertising standards, clearer total cost disclosures, and a prohibition on allowing consumers to e-sign RPAs without prior viewing. Acima must also ensure that the cash price disclosed to consumers does not exceed the retailer's cash price and must not mislead consumers about their termination rights. For a period of five years, Acima will not report to national consumer reporting agencies for RPAs originated after the effective date, though it may continue to provide data to specialty firms. The company is also required to implement robust oversight and training for its retail partners and conduct annual compliance reviews, submitting three annual reports to the multistate Executive Committee. These measures are intended to ensure ongoing adherence to the settlement terms and prevent future deceptive practices.
Beyond the Headlines
The Acima settlement highlights a broader trend in consumer protection where state attorneys general are actively scrutinizing business practices, particularly in sectors that cater to consumers with limited financial options. The absence of an explicit prohibition on leasing services in this settlement, despite some states having such bans, suggests a lack of nationwide consensus among AGs on this specific issue. This could indicate ongoing debates and varying regulatory approaches to rent-to-own models across different states. The case also underscores the increasing focus on transparency in financial disclosures and the prevention of predatory practices that can trap consumers in cycles of debt. The detailed injunctive terms, covering everything from advertising to credit reporting and retailer oversight, reflect a comprehensive effort to reform industry practices. This settlement could serve as a precedent for future investigations and regulatory actions against other companies in the rent-to-own or similar industries, prompting a reevaluation of business models to ensure compliance with consumer protection laws.













