What's Happening?
Hawaii is experiencing a significant decline in visitor survey participation and a subsequent loss of critical tourism data following the state's transition from paper agricultural declaration forms to the digital Akamai Arrival system. The shift, which
began on March 1, 2025, initially removed tourism questions from the mandatory declaration. Although these questions were later reinstated, participation in the tourism section remains substantially lower than under the previous paper-based system. Jennifer Chun, director of tourism research at the Department of Business, Economic Development and Tourism (DBEDT), noted that while 88% of travelers complete the digital agricultural declaration, only 23% proceed to the separate tourism survey. This has led to a drop in daily survey responses from approximately 11,000 paper forms to about 3,800 digital submissions, with only about 1,400 fully completed. As a result, DBEDT has suspended publishing visitor statistics for Molokai and Lanai due to insufficient data.
Why It's Important?
The loss of comprehensive visitor data poses a significant challenge for Hawaii's tourism industry, which heavily relies on this information for strategic planning, marketing investments, and understanding market trends. Tourism agencies, policymakers, and businesses use this data to make informed decisions about resource allocation, product development, and future investments. Without reliable and detailed visitor characteristics, the ability to tailor marketing efforts, assess traveler behavior, and anticipate tourism's impact on the islands is severely hampered. This data gap particularly affects smaller islands like Molokai and Lanai, where accurate visitor figures are crucial for community-driven destination management plans. Economists and industry leaders, such as Paul Brewbaker and Keith Vieira, have expressed concerns about the reduced reliability of tourism metrics and the potential for poor decision-making in a sector vital to Hawaii's economy.
What's Next?
State agencies are actively exploring solutions to increase tourism survey participation and improve the technology linking Akamai Arrival with the tourism survey. State Senator Glenn Wakai, a proponent of digitizing the agricultural form, acknowledges the concerns but believes the current 23% digital response rate is still statistically meaningful. He advocates for incentivizing survey completion through 'gamification,' offering coupons or discounts from local businesses. Industry leaders like Keith Vieira and Jerry Gibson support incentives but caution against mandatory participation, which could negatively impact visitor goodwill. Gibson also suggests exploring alternative data collection methods, such as aggregating information directly from industry sources like airlines and hotels. The ongoing efforts aim to restore the integrity and comprehensiveness of Hawaii's visitor data to support the state's crucial tourism sector.
Beyond the Headlines
This situation highlights a broader challenge in the digital transformation of public services: the potential for unintended consequences on data collection and analysis. While digitization often aims for efficiency, it can inadvertently create gaps in critical information if user engagement and data integrity are not carefully managed during the transition. The debate over mandatory versus incentivized participation in surveys also touches upon privacy concerns and the balance between data collection for public good and individual autonomy. The reliance on tourism data for economic planning in Hawaii underscores how seemingly administrative changes can have profound impacts on an entire state's economic health and policy-making capabilities, emphasizing the need for robust pilot programs and parallel systems during such transitions.













