What's Happening?
Master Limited Partnerships (MLPs) such as Plains All American Pipeline and Western Midstream Partners, despite offering high distributions, can create tax liabilities within Roth IRAs. While Roth IRAs are generally tax-exempt, their partnership structure
can trigger Unrelated Business Taxable Income (UBTI). This issue arises from four key legal provisions: Roth IRAs are treated like other individual retirement plans unless specified otherwise; IRAs are tax-exempt but subject to UBTI; an account owning a partnership interest must count its share of the partnership's business income, whether distributed or not; and a $1,000 deduction is allowed against this income. If the gross income from an unrelated business within the Roth IRA reaches $1,000 or more, the account is required to file Form 990-T. Both Plains All American and Western Midstream operate businesses involved in crude oil, natural gas, and related services, generating income that falls under this partnership rule. Plains All American pays $1.67 annually per unit, yielding about 7.0%, while Western Midstream pays $3.72 annually per unit, yielding about 9.3%. Both partnerships have increased their distributions since 2020.
Why It's Important?
This situation is important for U.S. investors utilizing Roth IRAs for retirement planning, particularly those seeking high-yield investments. The primary benefit of a Roth IRA is tax-free growth and withdrawals in retirement. However, holding MLPs can undermine this advantage by introducing a tax obligation, requiring the filing of Form 990-T and potentially incurring taxes on income that was intended to be tax-free. This complexity can deter investors who prefer a straightforward, tax-advantaged retirement vehicle. Furthermore, some MLP distributions are classified as return of capital, which defers tax until units are sold, even in taxable accounts. This means the tax savings offered by a Roth IRA on MLPs might be less significant compared to other high-yield investments like C-corp dividends, where taxes are typically paid annually. Investors must carefully consider the administrative burden and potential tax implications before including MLPs in their Roth IRA portfolios, as it can lead to unexpected tax filings and costs.
What's Next?
Investors currently holding MLPs in their Roth IRAs, or those considering such investments, will need to consult with tax professionals to understand their specific UBTI exposure. They should review their K-1 forms from each partnership to determine the allocated business income and assess if the cumulative amount exceeds the $1,000 threshold for filing Form 990-T. Custodians may also charge fees for filing this form, adding to the administrative cost. Investors seeking income without account-level tax filings may explore alternative high-yield investments that report on a 1099, such as business development companies, mortgage REITs, or energy companies structured as C-corporations. The ongoing performance and distribution policies of MLPs like Plains All American and Western Midstream will continue to influence investor decisions, as will any future changes in tax regulations concerning retirement accounts and partnership income.
Beyond the Headlines
The issue of MLPs in Roth IRAs highlights a broader tension between the desire for high-yield investments and the complexities of tax law within retirement accounts. It underscores the importance of understanding the specific legal structures of investment vehicles and their interaction with tax-advantaged accounts. While the intent of Roth IRAs is to simplify retirement savings by making withdrawals tax-free, the partnership structure of MLPs introduces a layer of complexity that can negate some of these benefits. This situation also raises questions about investor education and the need for clear guidance on less common investment scenarios within retirement plans. The ethical dimension involves ensuring that investors are fully aware of potential tax liabilities, even in accounts designed for tax-free growth, to prevent unexpected financial burdens and administrative overhead. This scenario could also prompt discussions among policymakers regarding potential clarifications or adjustments to tax codes to better align the treatment of various investment types within retirement vehicles.













