What's Happening?
Buffalo Bills running back James Cook, who had a standout season in 2025, has been ranked outside the top 5 in a preseason running back ranking by SI.com. Despite leading the NFL in rushing yards and earning the franchise's first rushing title in over
50 years, Cook was placed as the league's No. 8 back. His performance last season included rushing for 1,621 yards and achieving over 100 yards in nine games. Cook's role in the Bills' offense has been significant, with the team relying heavily on both his and quarterback Josh Allen's rushing abilities. Some analysts, like Ralph Ventre from SI.com, have defended Cook, highlighting his consistent improvement and three consecutive 1,000-yard seasons.
Why It's Important?
The ranking of James Cook outside the top 5 despite his impressive 2025 season raises questions about the criteria used in preseason evaluations. Cook's performance is crucial for the Buffalo Bills, as their offensive strategy heavily depends on his rushing capabilities. The ranking could impact perceptions of Cook's value and influence contract negotiations or endorsements. Additionally, it reflects broader trends in how running backs are evaluated in the NFL, potentially affecting other players in similar positions. The support from analysts and teammates underscores Cook's importance to the team and his potential to influence the Bills' success in the upcoming season.
What's Next?
As the new NFL season approaches, James Cook is expected to continue playing a central role in the Buffalo Bills' offense. With the addition of wide receiver DJ Moore, defenses may focus more on the passing game, potentially opening up more opportunities for Cook. The team's offensive coordinator, Joe Brady, might also integrate Cook more into the passing attack. Cook's performance in the upcoming season will be closely watched, especially in light of his preseason ranking. His ability to maintain or exceed his previous performance could alter perceptions and rankings in future evaluations.
