What's Happening?
Swiss Re Institute has released a new sigma report forecasting an acceleration in global non-life insurance premium growth over the next two years, but also a significant erosion of the industry's profitability cushion. While non-life insurer Return on Equity
(ROE) stood at 12.7% in 2026, it is projected to decline to 10.3% in 2027 and further towards the cost-of-capital, estimated at 7.3%, over the medium term. This decline is attributed to increasing competition driving down prices, even as risks become more complex. The report indicates that industry-wide underwriting margins are expected to slide from 4.4% of premiums earned in 2026 to 1.7% in 2027, and to barely above 0% in 2028, a level consistent with the 2016–2022 average during the last global soft cycle. High non-life profitability, partly driven by strong investment income, is prolonging this soft market, but this support is expected to fade as lower prices earn through portfolios.
Why It's Important?
This forecast from Swiss Re Institute is crucial for the U.S. insurance and reinsurance markets, as it signals a period of tightening margins and increased selectivity in underwriting. The projected decline in ROE towards the cost-of-capital means that insurers will find it harder to generate significant profits, potentially leading to more conservative risk-taking and a greater focus on efficiency. This could impact the availability and pricing of insurance products for businesses and individuals across the U.S., particularly in areas prone to complex and interconnected risks like natural catastrophes. The shift from pricing-led to exposure-led premium growth suggests that future growth will depend more on an expanding base of insurable assets, such as those related to AI-driven capital expenditure and emerging markets, rather than simply higher prices. This necessitates a strategic re-evaluation for U.S. insurers to adapt to a more challenging underwriting environment.
What's Next?
As the profitability cushion erodes, Swiss Re suggests that insurers may become more selective in deploying capacity, despite abundant capital. This increased selectivity is expected to lead to greater differentiation in pricing and growth across various risk pools. The convergence of three factors—exposure-led premium growth, increased market fragmentation and selectivity, and the growing complexity of risks—is anticipated to limit how far pricing and terms can soften. However, the report also warns that claims severity pressures will persist due to a volatile risk backdrop and inflation in insurance-relevant categories. The industry will likely see a gradual stabilization of underwriting conditions as ROE approaches the cost of capital. Insurers will need to focus on understanding interconnected risks and deploying capital strategically to provide sustainable protection, potentially through innovative solutions for new risk classes like those associated with artificial intelligence.
Beyond the Headlines
The erosion of profitability in the non-life insurance sector has deeper implications beyond financial statements. It highlights the increasing difficulty in accurately pricing and managing risks in a world characterized by growing interconnectedness and complexity, including climate change and technological advancements. The 'soft market' conditions, prolonged by past profitability, underscore a potential disconnect between perceived risk and actual market pricing. This situation could lead to a re-evaluation of risk models and underwriting practices across the industry. Furthermore, the emphasis on 'sustainable protection' by Swiss Re's CEO P&C Reinsurance UK & Ireland, Jason Richards, suggests a growing recognition that the industry's role extends beyond mere financial coverage to actively contributing to risk mitigation and resilience in society. This could spur greater collaboration between insurers, governments, and other stakeholders to address systemic risks more effectively.













