What's Happening?
Maybelline has updated its iconic tagline, 'Maybe she's born with it. Maybe it's Maybelline,' to 'Maybe. We’re born with it. Maybe. It’s Maybelline.' This change, implemented 35 years after the original, aims to appeal more effectively to Gen Z consumers
by adopting a more 'self-directed' and 'inclusive' perspective. According to Sandrine Jolly, Maybelline’s global brand president, the rebrand shifts from an observer's viewpoint to a collective and empowering message. The new marketing campaign features Miley Cyrus as a brand ambassador, promoting a new global platform titled 'The Beauty of Infinite Possibility,' which emphasizes self-expression and reinvention. However, the rebrand has garnered mixed reactions, particularly from the professional advertising community. Many copywriters on LinkedIn have criticized the new tagline, with some speculating it was generated by AI. Allure Magazine described it as 'copy editor rage bait,' highlighting the strong negative response from industry professionals regarding its grammatical structure and perceived lack of impact compared to the original.
Why It's Important?
This rebrand by Maybelline highlights the challenges faced by heritage brands in adapting their messaging to resonate with younger, digitally native audiences like Gen Z. The mixed feedback underscores the delicate balance between modernizing a brand's image and preserving its established identity and recognition. A well-known tagline is a significant asset, and altering it carries substantial risk, as evidenced by the professional backlash. The criticism from advertising professionals suggests a potential disconnect between corporate marketing strategies and the creative standards valued within the industry. This situation could influence how other established brands approach similar rebrands, potentially leading to more cautious or nuanced strategies. Furthermore, the attempt to make the tagline more 'inclusive' and 'self-directed' reflects broader societal trends where consumers expect brands to align with values of empowerment and individuality. However, the execution of this shift, particularly the grammatical changes, has proven controversial, indicating that intent does not always translate into effective communication. The use of a celebrity like Miley Cyrus aims to bridge this gap, but the core message's reception remains a critical point of discussion.
What's Next?
Maybelline will likely continue to push its new global platform, 'The Beauty of Infinite Possibility,' with Miley Cyrus as its face, hoping that consistent exposure will eventually lead to greater acceptance among Gen Z and the broader public. The company may need to address the professional criticism more directly, perhaps by clarifying the strategic thinking behind the grammatical changes or by emphasizing the broader campaign's positive aspects. Other brands observing Maybelline's experience might conduct more extensive market research and focus group testing before making significant changes to long-standing brand elements. This situation could also spark further debate within the advertising industry about the role of AI in creative processes and the importance of human-led copywriting. The long-term success of the rebrand will depend on its ability to genuinely connect with Gen Z consumers and whether the new tagline can achieve the same level of cultural shorthand and memorability as its predecessor, despite the initial mixed reception.
Beyond the Headlines
The Maybelline rebrand touches upon deeper cultural and linguistic implications in marketing. The original tagline's enduring success lay in its simplicity and evocative nature, becoming a part of popular culture. The new version, with its fragmented structure and explicit attempt at inclusivity, reflects a contemporary marketing trend to be overtly communicative about brand values. However, this can sometimes lead to a loss of poetic brevity and memorability. The debate also highlights the generational divide in communication styles; what might seem grammatically awkward to older generations or advertising professionals might be perceived differently by Gen Z, who are accustomed to more informal and fragmented digital communication. This case study could become a benchmark for discussions on how brands navigate the tension between maintaining heritage and evolving for new audiences, particularly concerning the nuances of language and cultural resonance. It also raises questions about the perceived authenticity of brand messaging when it appears to be overly engineered to fit a demographic, potentially leading to accusations of 'woke washing' if not executed with genuine understanding and subtlety.













