What's Happening?
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit is set to hear oral arguments on November 16, 2026, regarding a challenge to the National Labor Relations Board’s (NLRB) 2020 joint employer rule. This legal challenge represents the latest development in a prolonged
period of litigation surrounding the definition of a joint employer. According to Partner Patrick Muldowney, who was quoted in a Law360 Employment Authority article, the court's review will likely concentrate on whether the rule aligns with common law principles and if it is permissible under the National Labor Relations Act. The court will also consider the policy objectives the rule aims to promote. Muldowney also indicated that while the U.S. Supreme Court's Loper Bright decision, concerning judicial deference to agency actions, could influence the D.C. Circuit's review, it is not expected to be a decisive factor in this specific case.
Why It's Important?
The D.C. Circuit's decision on the NLRB's 2020 joint employer rule carries significant implications for businesses and labor relations across the United States. A ruling that upholds or overturns the rule could redefine the responsibilities and liabilities of companies that contract with other entities for labor, particularly in sectors like franchising, staffing, and construction. If the rule is upheld, it could expand the scope of joint employer relationships, potentially making more companies jointly responsible for the labor practices of their contractors. This could lead to increased litigation risks, compliance costs, and a need for businesses to re-evaluate their operational structures. Conversely, if the rule is struck down, it could limit the circumstances under which companies are deemed joint employers, potentially reducing their legal obligations and providing more flexibility in their business models. The outcome will directly impact how employers manage their workforce and engage with third-party labor providers.
What's Next?
Following the oral arguments on November 16, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit will deliberate and issue its ruling on the challenge to the NLRB's 2020 joint employer rule. The decision will either affirm, modify, or vacate the existing rule, setting a new precedent for how joint employment is defined and applied under the National Labor Relations Act. Depending on the outcome, businesses, labor unions, and the NLRB itself will need to adjust their strategies and operations. If the rule is overturned, the NLRB may consider issuing a new rule or appealing the decision to the Supreme Court. Employers will need to closely monitor the court's decision and potentially revise their employment contracts, policies, and practices to ensure compliance with the updated legal framework. The ruling could also prompt further legislative efforts to clarify the definition of joint employment.
Beyond the Headlines
The ongoing legal battle over the joint employer rule highlights a fundamental tension in modern labor law: how to balance the rights of workers with the operational flexibility of businesses, especially in an economy increasingly reliant on contract and contingent labor. The D.C. Circuit's decision will not only have immediate legal consequences but could also shape the future of work by influencing business models and employment relationships. A broader definition of joint employment could empower workers by extending collective bargaining rights and protections to those employed by contractors, potentially leading to improved wages and working conditions. Conversely, a narrower definition could favor businesses by reducing regulatory burdens and fostering innovation through flexible labor arrangements. This case also underscores the broader debate about judicial deference to administrative agencies, a principle that could be further refined by the court's interpretation of the Loper Bright decision, even if not a decisive factor in this specific instance.













