What's Happening?
The English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act 2026 is set to prohibit upward-only rent review (UORR) provisions in most new commercial leases starting in 2027. This legislative change will fundamentally alter how commercial rents are determined,
aiming to ensure rents more accurately reflect current market conditions and alleviate the burden on tenants. Traditionally, commercial leases often included UORR clauses, which allowed rents to increase with market improvements but prevented decreases during market downturns, benefiting landlords and investors. While the exact implementation date is yet to be announced, the Act will not affect existing leases or those granted under unconditional agreements for lease that include UORR before the ban takes effect. Rural estates, which have diversified beyond traditional farming into ventures like farm shops, cafes, and industrial units, will need to adapt their leasing strategies, as new leases for these properties may be impacted by the legislation.
Why It's Important?
This legislative change is significant for the commercial property sector, particularly for rural landowners with diversified portfolios. The ban on UORR aims to create a more equitable rental market by allowing rents to fluctuate with market conditions, potentially reducing financial pressure on tenants. However, it also introduces new considerations for landlords who previously relied on UORR for predictable rental growth and protection against inflation. While Farm Business Tenancies (FBTs) already incorporate flexible rent review mechanisms, diversified rural estates will need to re-evaluate their leasing practices. Landlords may explore alternative rental mechanisms such as open market rent reviews (allowing for increases or decreases), stepped rents, fixed percentage increases, or index-linked reviews, provided they are not upward-only. The shift could lead to increased uncertainty for landlords regarding future rental income, potentially impacting property valuations and lending arrangements that were based on minimum anticipated rents.
What's Next?
Although the changes are slated for 2027, landlords are advised to begin assessing how these reforms will influence future lettings of diversified-use spaces. Key areas for review include heads of terms, lease precedents, renewal provisions, estate management strategies, valuation assumptions, and lending arrangements. Landowners considering new lettings may also explore incorporating alternative 'floating' rent review mechanisms into their standard documentation, such as those that allow for the higher of two alternative review methods, which is currently permitted. The agricultural sector, already accustomed to flexible FBT rents, may experience less disruption, but diversified rural estates face more substantial adjustments. Seeking legal advice when negotiating new leases will be crucial for landowners to navigate the evolving regulatory landscape and ensure compliance.
Beyond the Headlines
The ban on upward-only rent reviews could have broader implications for the commercial real estate investment landscape. While intended to benefit tenants, there's a possibility that tenants could inadvertently be worse off if, for example, they move to inflation-linked indexed rents that increase even when the market is weak, whereas an open market rent (even if upward-only) might not have risen. This highlights a potential tension between legislative intent and practical outcomes. The shift could also influence how financial institutions assess risk and provide financing for commercial properties, as the predictability of rental income, a key factor in loan assessments, may become more variable. Furthermore, the legislation underscores a broader governmental push to rebalance power dynamics between landlords and tenants, potentially setting a precedent for similar reforms in other sectors or regions.













