The musical "La Cage aux Folles" embarked on a complex creative journey before its successful Broadway debut in 1983. The initial idea stemmed from Allan Carr, who, after producing the hit film "Grease," aimed to bring a musical version of the 1978 film "La Cage aux Folles" to Broadway. However, he could only secure the rights to the original French play, not the film. This limitation set the stage for a new adaptation, distinct from its cinematic
predecessor, and led to a series of creative shifts and collaborations that ultimately shaped the groundbreaking musical.
Early Development and Creative Team Changes
Carr's initial attempt involved hiring Jay Presson Allen to write the book and Maury Yeston to compose the score for an Americanized version titled "The Queen of Basin Street," set in New Orleans. Mike Nichols was slated to direct, with Tommy Tune as choreographer. However, after Carr found executive producers Fritz Holt and Barry Brown, the entire creative team Carr had assembled was immediately fired. This led to lawsuits, though only Yeston ultimately won, later collecting a small royalty from "La Cage aux Folles."
Holt and Brown, who had previously produced the 1974 revival of "Gypsy," then approached Arthur Laurents to direct their new venture. Laurents, initially not a fan of drag or camp entertainment, was skeptical about finding investors for a gay-themed project, especially during the early years of the AIDS epidemic when homophobia was heightened. He agreed to direct primarily out of friendship with Holt and Brown, but his interest grew significantly when Harvey Fierstein and Jerry Herman committed to the project, bringing a new vision and energy to the production.
Crafting the Story and Music
According to Laurents, when he first met with Fierstein and Herman, they had restored the original play's title and locale but lacked a script or even a plot outline. All they had was Herman's song "I Am What I Am." Laurents immediately envisioned this song as an emotional outburst to close the first act, claiming his concept inspired the direction Fierstein and Herman took in writing the musical. Herman, however, tells a different story, stating that Fierstein arrived with a fiery scene for the end of Act I that included the words "I am what I am," prompting Herman to quickly compose the song.
With gay-activist Fierstein and the politically minded Laurents on board, there was a potential for the show to become a polemic on gay rights. However, Jerry Herman served as a moderating influence. Having experienced disappointments with darker-themed shows, Herman was eager to create a mainstream, emotional, and optimistic song-and-dance entertainment that would appeal to middle-class audiences. The team ultimately opted to create "a charming, colorful, great-looking musical comedy – an an old-fashioned piece of entertainment," as Herman recalled. This approach allowed them to convey their gay-themed message with greater impact by delivering it in a sweetly entertaining manner.
Rehearsals, Performances, and Last-Minute Adjustments
Fierstein, Herman, and Laurents met daily in Herman's Manhattan townhouse to develop the musical. Limited to the Poiret play as their source, they focused the plot on the naturalness of Georges and Albin's relationship, emphasizing how their son could accept a man as his "mother." Theoni V. Aldredge was hired as costume designer to ensure Albin was as glamorous an entertainer as possible.
During rehearsals, there were concerns about Gene Barry's performance as Georges, with many supporting his replacement. However, finding a suitable replacement proved difficult. Just before opening night, Laurents instructed Barry to always look into George Hearn's eyes when they were on stage, to convey the depth of the couple's feelings. Laurents also directed Georges to introduce the club acts with more flourish, like an "aria." These last-minute adjustments helped Barry grasp his character, leading to a Tony nomination, while Hearn won the award for his role as Albin. The Boston tryout, despite Herman's initial panic about the city's conservatism, received an enthusiastic reception, confirming the show's broad appeal.













