Goldwyn Pictures Corporation, a significant entity in the early American motion picture industry, operated from its founding in 1916 until its merger in 1924. This company played a crucial role in the formation of one of Hollywood's most iconic studios, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer. Established by Samuel Goldfish (who later legally changed his name to Samuel Goldwyn) and Broadway producers Edgar and Archibald Selwyn, Goldwyn Pictures began with ambitions to make
its mark in the burgeoning film world. Its journey was characterized by strategic moves, creative endeavors, financial challenges, and eventual consolidation, reflecting the dynamic and often turbulent nature of early cinema.
Founding and Early Operations in Fort Lee
Goldwyn Pictures was officially founded on November 19, 1916. Samuel Goldfish, an executive who had previously co-founded Lasky's Feature Play Company, joined forces with the Selwyn brothers, using an amalgamation of their last names to create the company's identity. The initial team was further strengthened by Margaret Mayo, Edgar Selwyn's wife and a playwright, who joined as a writer, and Broadway producer Arthur Hopkins, who came on board as director general. In its nascent stages, Goldwyn Pictures established its operations in Fort Lee, New Jersey, a hub for many early American film studios. The company initially rented production facilities from Solax Studios, a common practice in the early industry.
The company's first film release was "Polly of the Circus," an adaptation of Mayo's 1907 play, which premiered in September 1917 and starred Mae Marsh. By April 1917, Goldwyn Pictures expanded its footprint in Fort Lee by agreeing to rent Universal Pictures studios, which boasted the second-largest stage at the time. The company was ambitious, operating two film companies with plans for more, aiming to complete 12 films by September 1, 1917. A unique strategy was to withhold distribution until advanced footage could be shown to theaters. To enhance its artistic standing, Goldfish also forged an association with Columbia University through Professor Victor Freeburg's Photoplay Writing class in 1917. Goldwyn Pictures also distributed films from other production companies, such as Marie Dressler's Dressler Producing Corporation film, "The Scrub Lady," in 1917. The company faced early censorship challenges, being forced in October 1917 to replace "The Eternal Magalene" with "Fighting Odds," both starring Maxine Elliott, after Pennsylvania and Chicago censors disapproved of the former.
Shifting Strategies and Westward Expansion
As Goldwyn Pictures navigated its early years, it encountered both creative and financial hurdles. The film "Thais," starring Mary Garden and released in late 1917, proved to be a costly loss for the company. This financial setback, followed by another with "Thais" being the company's second costly loss, prompted Samuel Goldfish to implement budget cuts. He shifted away from using expensive theater divas for film crossovers and reduced the number of design-driven films. Instead, the company began to focus on comedies featuring stars like Madge Kennedy and Mabel Normand. In January 1918, Goldfish prematurely announced the signing of director Raoul Walsh, who still had two years remaining on his contract with Fox, indicating some of the operational complexities of the era.
A significant strategic move occurred in August 1918 when Goldwyn Pictures signed Will Rogers, a popular Broadway Follies performer, to star in Rex Beach's production, "Laughing Bill Hyde," filmed at the Fort Lee studio for a September release. That same year, the company made a pivotal acquisition, purchasing the Triangle Studios in Culver City. This marked a westward expansion, with Goldfish heading to Culver City, California, in 1918 to open operations there. While this move increased film expenses, it positioned the company for future growth. It was in December of this year that Samuel Goldfish legally changed his name to Samuel Goldwyn, solidifying his personal brand with the company's identity.
Financial Investments, Vertical Integration, and Eventual Merger
The company continued to evolve with new investments and strategic initiatives. In 1919, Frank Joseph "Joe" Godsol became an investor in Goldwyn Pictures, bringing his experience from making deals for the Shubert Organization since 1912. Goldwyn began exploring vertical integration, a strategy adopted by other film companies like Loews Theaters/Metro Pictures and First National, which involved controlling production, distribution, and exhibition. The company considered renting the Astor Theatre for movie premieres. Instead, they entered into a stock swap and board seat agreement with the owners of the soon-to-open Capitol Theatre, headed by Messmore Kendall, partnering with Moredall Realty Corporation. However, the Moredall Board insisted that The Capitol Theatre operate independently and not rely solely on Goldwyn films.
By 1920, Goldwyn Pictures had a significant operational footprint, owning its Culver City studio and renting two New York studios, in addition to its operations in Fort Lee. Despite these expansions, internal conflicts arose. Samuel Goldwyn himself left the company in 1922 due to numerous personality clashes on the board. Frank Joseph Godsol then assumed the presidency of Goldwyn Pictures in 1922. As the company faced increasing difficulties, Godsol initiated discussions with Marcus Loew in 1924 regarding a merger with Loew's Metro Pictures. After extensive negotiations, all parties agreed. Louis B. Mayer, upon learning of the impending merger, contacted Loew and Godsol to include his Louis B. Mayer Productions into the new entity. This culminated in the formation of the major studio Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer on April 17, 1924. The merged studio inherited Goldwyn's Culver City facility, where it remained until 1986, and also retained Goldwyn's iconic Leo the Lion logo, a lasting legacy of the original company.













