On November 16, 1776, a pivotal moment in early American history unfolded on the Caribbean island of Sint Eustatius. This event, known as The First Salute, marked the initial recognition of the United States by a foreign power, just months after the American Declaration of Independence. The American ship *Andrew Doria*, flying the new American flag, arrived in the harbor of Sint Eustatius. Following maritime custom, the *Andrew Doria* fired a salute,
which was then returned by cannon shots from Fort Oranje, under the command of Governor Johannes de Graaff. This seemingly simple exchange of salutes had profound diplomatic repercussions, particularly with Great Britain, and ultimately contributed to the outbreak of the Fourth Anglo-Dutch War.
The Genesis of Recognition
In July 1776, the thirteen North American colonies had formally declared their independence. The *Andrew Doria*'s arrival in Sint Eustatius was not merely a courtesy call; the ship intended to procure weapons and ammunition. As the first American vessel to enter the harbor flying the new American flag, its presence was significant. Governor De Graaff, upon receiving the *Andrew Doria*'s salute, ordered a reciprocal salute from Fort Oranje. This act was interpreted by the Americans as the first official recognition of the United States as a sovereign nation by a foreign entity. De Graaff further solidified this recognition by hosting a celebratory feast for the captain and inviting all Americans on the island.
London's Furious Reaction
The British reaction to The First Salute was swift and furious. English ships present in the harbor during the salute immediately sailed to the neighboring island of Saint Kitts to report the incident. London demanded a public condemnation of the salute from the States-General and the dismissal of Governor De Graaff. De Graaff was summoned to The Hague for questioning, but he skillfully delayed his journey with various excuses, including family matters and seasickness. When he finally arrived in 1778, he presented an extensive defense, which reportedly contained distortions and falsehoods. The States-General accepted his defense, partly because Amsterdam merchants were also profiting significantly from trade with Sint Eustatius.
Escalation to War
For the British, De Graaff's continued tenure, despite their demands, further demonstrated the Dutch Republic's unreliability as an ally. This perceived unreliability was compounded by the Dutch failure to support Britain in its fight against the American revolutionaries. The situation worsened when the Dutch Republic expressed its intention to join the League of Armed Neutrality in late 1780. This Russian-initiated alliance aimed to protect merchant fleets from attacks by British naval vessels. The final catalyst for war was the discovery of a trade contract on a British-captured ship, belonging to Henry Laurens, the American ambassador-designate to The Hague. On December 20, 1780, the English declared war on the Dutch, initiating the Fourth Anglo-Dutch War.
The Plundering of Sint Eustatius
Admiral George Rodney was tasked with capturing Sint Eustatius. Rodney harbored a personal grudge against the island, as materials for repairs had been sent to a French fleet after he had heavily damaged it. On February 3, 1781, Rodney arrived in the harbor with seventeen naval ships. Governor De Graaff, facing such overwhelming force, surrendered the island without resistance. Rodney proceeded to take all inhabitants of the island prisoner, deporting them to other Caribbean islands and Great Britain. He ordered the entire island to be plundered, auctioning off the spoils, though he reserved a substantial portion for himself. Rodney's actions were met with criticism, including a notable speech in the House of Commons by opposition leader Edmund Burke, who condemned the plundering.













