The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) was not only a framework for reducing trade barriers but also included specific mechanisms for resolving disputes that arose among its member countries. These mechanisms, particularly Chapter 19 and Chapter 11, became central to many of the agreement's controversies and criticisms. While designed to ensure fair application of trade laws and protect investments, these chapters also sparked debate over national
sovereignty and the balance between economic interests and public welfare.
Chapter 19: Antidumping and Countervailing Duty Disputes
Chapter 19 of NAFTA established a unique trade dispute mechanism for antidumping and countervailing duty (AD/CVD) determinations. Instead of, or in addition to, conventional judicial review within a country's domestic courts, NAFTA parties had the option to appeal decisions to binational panels. These panels were composed of five citizens from the two relevant NAFTA countries, typically lawyers experienced in international trade law. The panel's role was to determine whether final agency determinations involving AD/CVD conformed with the country's domestic law, examining if the agency's decision was supported by "substantial evidence." This standard granted significant deference to the domestic agency. Chapter 19 was considered an anomaly in international dispute settlement because it did not apply international law but required a panel of individuals from multiple countries to re-examine the application of one country's domestic law. Controversial trade disputes, such as the U.S.–Canada softwood lumber dispute, were litigated before these Chapter 19 panels.
Extraordinary Challenge Committees
Decisions made by Chapter 19 panels could be challenged before a NAFTA extraordinary challenge committee. However, this committee did not function as an ordinary appeal body. Its power was limited to vacating or remanding a decision only if it involved a significant and material error that threatened the integrity of the NAFTA dispute settlement system. As of January 2006, no NAFTA party had successfully challenged a Chapter 19 panel's decision before an extraordinary challenge committee, indicating the high bar for such challenges.
Chapter 11: Investor-State Dispute Settlement
Another highly contentious aspect of NAFTA was the investor-state dispute settlement obligations outlined in Chapter 11. This chapter allowed corporations or individuals to sue Mexico, Canada, or the United States for compensation if actions taken by those governments, or by entities for whom they were responsible at international law (such as provincial, state, or municipal governments), violated international law. This provision drew criticism from groups in all three countries who argued it did not adequately consider social and environmental factors. For example, Metalclad, an American corporation, was awarded $15.6 million from Mexico after a Mexican municipality refused a construction permit for a hazardous waste landfill, despite federal approval. The NAFTA panel found the municipality lacked authority to ban construction based on environmental concerns.
Notable Chapter 11 Cases and Criticisms
Several high-profile cases highlighted the complexities and criticisms of Chapter 11. Methanex Corporation, a Canadian company, filed a $970 million suit against the United States, claiming a California ban on methyl tert-butyl ether (MTBE) harmed its methanol sales. This claim was rejected, with the company ordered to pay $3 million to the U.S. government in costs, based on the reasoning that a non-discriminatory regulation for a public purpose, enacted with due process, is not deemed expropriatory unless specific commitments were made to the investor. In another instance, Eli Lilly and Company presented a $500 million claim against Canada regarding its drug patent legislation. Apotex also sued the U.S. for $520 million over lost opportunity due to an FDA generic drug decision. Critics, including the Council of Canadians, challenged the constitutionality of Chapter 11, though they were unsuccessful in court. The existence of Chapter 11 also created an anomaly where Canadian companies facing similar issues as foreign investors, such as permit rescissions by Quebec legislation, did not have the right to pursue a NAFTA claim, making it harder for them to win compensation in Canadian courts due to property rights being provincial matters.