Susan B. Anthony, a towering figure in the women's suffrage movement, was not merely a participant in the fight for voting rights; she was a master strategist and publicist. Her arrest in November 1872 for voting in the presidential election, an act that violated federal law, could have been a setback. Instead, Anthony skillfully transformed this legal challenge into an unprecedented opportunity to galvanize public support and educate the nation about
women's right to vote. Her actions before and during her trial demonstrate a deliberate and effective use of her personal legal battle as a powerful tool for political advocacy.
Orchestrating Publicity and Legal Defense
Anthony's strategic approach began even before her arrest. On November 1, 1872, when she and her sisters successfully registered to vote, Anthony immediately went to a newspaper office to provide an interview. This ensured that news of their registration would spread, drawing attention to their challenge of the voting laws. When some newspapers called for the arrest of the election inspectors who allowed them to register, Anthony returned to the registration office to reassure the inspectors, promising to cover any legal costs they might incur. This demonstrated her commitment and foresight, preparing for the legal battles ahead.
When warrants were issued for the women who had voted and the election inspectors, Anthony's arrest on November 18, 1872, became national news. She was the only one of the group to be indicted and brought to trial, making her case a focal point. Anthony chose Henry R. Selden, a respected lawyer and former Lieutenant Governor, as her attorney, and also secured John van Voorhis to represent the election inspectors. While bail was set for the arrested women, Anthony initially refused to post it, though her lawyer eventually did so. This refusal, though ultimately overridden, highlighted her willingness to endure legal consequences for her cause.
The Pre-Trial Speaking Tour: Educating the Jury Pool
Anthony recognized the immense public relations potential of her impending trial. She embarked on an extensive speaking tour across 29 towns and villages in Monroe County, New York, the very county where her trial was scheduled and from which her jurors would be selected. Her speech, titled "Is it a Crime for a U.S. Citizen to Vote?", was a direct appeal to the public and, implicitly, to potential jurors. In her speeches, she asserted that the Fourteenth Amendment granted her the right to vote, proclaiming, "We no longer petition Legislature or Congress to give us the right to vote. We appeal to women everywhere to exercise their too long neglected 'citizen's right to vote'."
Anthony's message was clear and compelling: "The only question left to be settled now, is: Are women persons? And I hardly believe any of our opponents will have the hardihood to say they are not. Being persons, then, women are citizens; and no State has a right to make any new law, or to enforce any old law, that shall abridge their privileges or immunities." Her speech was so impactful that it was printed in its entirety in one of the Rochester daily newspapers, further disseminating her arguments to a wide audience, including those who might serve on her jury. When the prosecutor moved the trial to Ontario County, Anthony responded by delivering speeches in every community there as well, ensuring that her message reached the new jury pool. This strategic use of public speaking transformed her legal defense into a powerful campaign for women's suffrage, demonstrating her unwavering commitment to the cause and her ability to leverage personal adversity for collective gain.













