Following the American Revolutionary War, the newly independent United States found itself in a precarious position. While the peace treaty granted independence, the governmental structure established by the Articles of Confederation proved to be largely unsettled and inadequate for the challenges ahead. The Articles, though envisioning a permanent confederation, granted very limited powers to the Congress, which was the sole federal institution.
This inherent weakness led to significant difficulties in governing the fast-growing nation and addressing its pressing economic and political issues.
A Government Lacking Essential Powers
One of the most critical limitations of the Articles of Confederation was the absence of a strong central authority. The document did not provide for a president, executive agencies, or a national judiciary. This meant there was no single executive to enforce laws or represent the nation consistently, and no unified judicial system to interpret laws or resolve disputes between states. The Congress, while having the power to make resolutions, lacked the means to ensure these resolutions were actually enforced by the individual states.
Furthermore, the Articles failed to establish a reliable tax base for the federal government. Congress could not levy taxes directly; instead, it had to request money from the states. These requests, known as requisitions, were seldom fully met. For instance, between 1781 and 1784, less than a million and a half dollars entered the treasury, even though governors had been asked for two million dollars in 1783 alone. This inability to generate revenue meant that Congress struggled to pay off the substantial state and national debts incurred during the war years, leading to a dire financial situation.
Economic Instability and Foreign Relations
The economic landscape under the Articles was fraught with challenges. Although the nation began to regain some prosperity after the war, American trade opportunities were severely restricted by the mercantilist policies of European governments. The British West Indies, for example, were closed to all staple products not carried in British-flagged ships, and France and Spain implemented similar policies. Simultaneously, new U.S. manufacturers faced intense competition from British products that became readily available again after the war.
The lack of a strong central government also hampered foreign relations. When John Adams went to London in 1785 as the first representative of the United States, he found it impossible to secure a treaty for unrestricted commerce. Demands were made for favors, and there was no assurance that individual states would adhere to any treaty. Adams recognized the necessity for states to grant Congress power over navigation laws or for states themselves to enact retaliatory measures against Britain. However, Congress had already tried and failed to gain power over navigation laws, and individual states acted independently, often to little effect. For instance, when some New England states closed their ports to British shipping, Connecticut quickly opened its own ports to profit, undermining any unified effort.
Internal Unrest and the Push for Revision
Domestically, the period under the Articles was marked by political unrest and economic anxiety. The Continental Congress's printing of paper money led to such depreciation that it became virtually worthless, giving rise to the expression "not worth a continental." Efforts by debtors to use popular government to erase their debts, coupled with the apparent inability of Congress to redeem public obligations, heightened the concerns of the political and economic elites who had led the Revolution. This gloomy situation was further aggravated by the Congress's failure to foster productive cooperation among states for commerce and economic development.
A significant event that highlighted the fragility of the government was Shays's Rebellion in 1786–87. This uprising of dissidents in western Massachusetts against the state court system directly threatened the stability of the state government. By 1787, Congress was unable to protect manufacturing and shipping, and state legislatures were either unwilling or unable to defend private contracts and public credit. Land speculators saw no prospect of rising values when the government could not secure its borders or protect its frontier population. These accumulating crises led to a growing consensus that the Articles of Confederation needed revision, ultimately paving the way for the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia.

















