In November 1933, a significant diplomatic shift occurred between the United States and the Soviet Union with the signing of the Roosevelt-Litvinov Recognition Agreement. This accord formally established diplomatic relations between the two nations, marking an end to a period of non-recognition and opening channels for official communication and exchange. The agreement was the culmination of efforts by President Franklin D. Roosevelt and Soviet Foreign
Minister Maxim Litvinov, who engaged in high-level discussions to address various points of contention and pave the way for a new era in their bilateral relationship.
The Path to Recognition
Prior to 1933, the United States had withheld diplomatic recognition from the Soviet government. However, by this time, there was a growing sentiment within the American business community and among newspaper editors favoring such recognition. The business sector, in particular, saw potential for large-scale trade with the Soviet Union, which was an attractive prospect during the Great Depression. The U.S. government also harbored hopes of securing some repayment on old tsarist debts and obtaining a commitment from the USSR not to support subversive movements within the United States.
President Roosevelt took the initiative to pursue recognition, working with his close advisor Henry Morgenthau Jr. and Russian expert William Bullitt, and notably bypassing the State Department in the initial stages. To gauge public sentiment, Roosevelt commissioned a survey of 1,100 newspaper editors, revealing that 63 percent favored recognition, while 27 percent were opposed. He also personally met with Catholic leaders to address their concerns, which stemmed from the persecution of religious believers and the systematic demolition of churches in the USSR during its anti-religious campaign from 1928 to 1941.
Key Provisions and Immediate Outcomes
Foreign Minister Maxim Litvinov was invited to Washington for a series of high-level meetings in November 1933. During these discussions, Litvinov and Roosevelt reached agreements on several crucial issues. One significant point was religious freedom for Americans working in the Soviet Union. The USSR also pledged not to interfere in internal American affairs and to ensure that no organization within the Soviet Union was working to harm the U.S. or overthrow its government by force. However, historical accounts suggest these promises were not honored by the Soviet side.
Both parties also agreed to postpone the complex question of old tsarist debts to a later date. Following these negotiations, Roosevelt announced the agreement on the resumption of normal relations, which was formalized with the signing of the Roosevelt-Litvinov agreements on November 16, 1933. The exchange of letters formalizing the agreement took place at 11:50 p.m. in Washington D.C. at the White House. William Bullitt was subsequently named as the first American ambassador to the USSR, serving from 1933 to 1936, while Alexander Troyanovsky became the first Soviet ambassador to the United States. Despite the initial hopes, historians note that both nations were soon disillusioned by the accord, with little progress on the debt issue and limited additional trade materializing.
Legal Ramifications and Executive Power
The Roosevelt-Litvinov Accords had significant legal implications within the United States, particularly concerning the scope of presidential power in foreign policy. The agreement, which involved an exchange of letters rather than a formal treaty ratified by the Senate, settled claims between the two countries. Its constitutionality was later tested in the Supreme Court case *United States v. Belmont*. The Court upheld the president's power, stating that the executive branch had the authority to determine the public policy of the United States regarding the Russian nationalization decrees without Senate consent. This ruling affirmed that the question of which government represents a foreign sovereign state is a political, not judicial, matter, to be decided by the political department of the government.
Another case, *United States v. Pink*, also arising from the Litvinov Agreement, further solidified the president's authority. In *Pink*, the Supreme Court ruled that New York State was interfering with the president's exclusive power over foreign affairs by refusing to turn over assets belonging to a Russian insurance company as per the Litvinov assignment. The Court ordered New York to pay the money to the federal government, emphasizing that the Fifth Amendment did not impede the full force and effect of the Litvinov Assignment. These cases underscored the executive's broad powers in conducting foreign relations, even through agreements not requiring Senate approval.













