The name "Criterion" has been associated with several significant publications in the literary and intellectual world, spanning different eras and geographical locations. These journals have served as platforms for critical thought, artistic expression, and cultural commentary, each leaving its unique mark on the intellectual landscape. From a prominent British literary magazine edited by a towering figure of modernism to an American counterpart and a contemporary
journal of cultural criticism, the name "Criterion" often signifies a commitment to high standards and thoughtful discourse in publishing.
The British Literary Magazine: T. S. Eliot's 'The Criterion'
One of the most notable publications bearing the name was *The Criterion*, a British literary magazine that ran from October 1922 to January 1939. This influential periodical was edited by the renowned poet and critic T. S. Eliot, who shaped its editorial direction and content. Initially, the magazine received financial backing from Lady Rothermere, providing it with the resources to attract significant contributions. Later in its history, *The Criterion* was acquired by Faber and Gwyer Publishing, further solidifying its institutional support.
Under Eliot's editorship, *The Criterion* became a vital forum for modernist literature and criticism. It featured works from some of the most celebrated writers of the era, including Virginia Woolf, Ezra Pound, and Marcel Proust. The magazine played a crucial role in disseminating new literary ideas and showcasing experimental writing, contributing significantly to the intellectual currents of the early 20th century. Its closure in 1939 marked the end of an important chapter in British literary modernism.
American Literary Ventures: 'The Criterion' and 'The New Criterion'
Across the Atlantic, an American literary magazine also bore the name *The Criterion*, published in New York from 1896 to 1905. This earlier American publication distinguished itself by featuring provocative articles and illustrations, suggesting a more daring or avant-garde approach for its time. While distinct from its British namesake, it shared the ambition of providing a platform for engaging and thought-provoking content within the literary sphere.
Decades later, in 1982, a new publication emerged in New York, explicitly referencing Eliot's journal: *The New Criterion*. Founded by Hilton Kramer, a former art critic for *The New York Times*, and Samuel Lipman, a pianist and music critic, *The New Criterion* positioned itself as a monthly literary magazine and journal of artistic and cultural criticism. It covers various aspects of culture, including poetry, theater, art, music, media, and books, and is currently edited by Roger Kimball and James Panero.
A Legacy of Critical Engagement
*The New Criterion* describes itself as a "monthly review of the arts and intellectual life," aiming to champion what it considers "best and most humanely vital in our cultural inheritance" while exposing what it deems "mendacious, corrosive, and spurious." The magazine is characterized by a modernist inclination and a political conservatism, a stance that sets it apart from many other publications of its kind. It regularly publishes special symposia on various themes, such as "Affirmative action and the law" and "Common-good conservatism: a debate," reflecting its engagement with contemporary intellectual and cultural issues.
Beyond these prominent examples, the name "Criterion" has also appeared in other publishing contexts, such as a philosophy journal in Catalan published from 1925 to 1969, and the *Jewish Criterion*, a weekly newspaper in Pittsburgh. This recurring use of the term across different publications underscores its association with standards, judgment, and critical evaluation within the world of print media and intellectual discourse.













