Ford Christopher Frick, who served as the third commissioner of Major League Baseball from 1951 to 1965, made several decisions during his tenure that sparked considerable debate and left a lasting impact on the sport. While he is remembered for his leadership in expanding the leagues and his role in the establishment of the Baseball Hall of Fame, some of his actions, particularly concerning record-keeping and rule adjustments, drew significant criticism.
These controversies highlight the complexities of managing a sport steeped in tradition while also adapting to its evolving landscape. His influence extended beyond administrative duties, touching upon the very fabric of how baseball's achievements were recognized and recorded.
The "Asterisk" Controversy of 1961
Perhaps Frick's most highly criticized decision as commissioner involved the single-season home run record in 1961. When Roger Maris challenged Babe Ruth's long-standing record of 60 home runs, Frick intervened with a ruling that caused widespread misunderstanding. He requested that baseball record-keepers distinguish between Ruth's record, achieved in a 154-game season, and Maris's potential new record, which would be set in the newly expanded 162-game season. Frick stated that a player must hit more than 60 home runs within the first 154 games to be considered the sole record holder.
This ruling led to the popular misconception that an "asterisk" was placed next to Maris's record. While Frick did call for some "distinctive mark" in the record books, the idea of an asterisk was immediately suggested by sportswriter Dick Young. It is important to note that Major League Baseball did not have direct control over official record books at that time, making Frick's directive more of a suggestion. Despite his friendship with Babe Ruth, Frick's authority as commissioner did not extend to unilaterally altering record books. The controversy eventually subsided, and prominent baseball record keepers later listed Maris as the single-season record holder without any special designation.
The Strike Zone Change and its Consequences
Another significant, and ultimately controversial, decision made during Frick's commissionership involved a change to the strike zone. In the early 1960s, there was a noticeable increase in individual batting achievements, prominently highlighted by Roger Maris's home run record. Concerned by the rising number of home runs across the major leagues, Frick successfully convinced team owners to agree to widen the strike zone before the 1963 season.
This alteration had immediate and profound effects on the game. The wider strike zone led to a significant decrease in batting averages and overall scoring. While this change inadvertently ushered in a remarkable era for pitchers, with many achieving career-best performances, it also contributed to a stagnation in attendance. The trend reached its peak in 1968, a season famously known as the "Year of the Pitcher," when American League teams collectively batted a mere .230. Recognizing the negative impact on offensive play and fan engagement, the strike zone was corrected back to its previous dimensions just a year later, in 1969. This episode illustrates Frick's willingness to implement rule changes to influence the game's dynamics, even if the outcomes were not always as intended or universally popular.
Legacy and Retirement
Frick announced in 1960 that he would likely retire when his contract expired in 1965. His remaining goals as commissioner included completing the expansion process and convincing Congress to allow each baseball league to set its own television policies. After his retirement, he remained involved with the Baseball Hall of Fame, serving as chairman of the board in 1966 and on the Veterans Committee from 1966 to 1969. He was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame by the Veterans Committee in 1970. Frick's decisions, both celebrated and criticized, undeniably shaped the course of Major League Baseball during a pivotal era of its history.













