Eugene O'Neill's "Hughie" is a concise, two-character play that offers a poignant glimpse into the human condition. Set in the summer of 1928, the entire drama unfolds in the lobby of a small hotel on a West
Side street in Midtown Manhattan. The play is primarily structured as a lengthy monologue delivered by Erie Smith, a small-time hustler, to Charlie Hughes, the hotel's new night clerk. Smith laments his downturn in luck since the death of Hughie, Hughes' predecessor, creating a narrative rich with themes of loneliness, illusion, and the need for connection. O'Neill penned this work in 1942, though its world premiere did not occur until 1958 in Sweden.
Origins and Early Productions
O'Neill's "Hughie" first saw the stage in 1958 at the Royal Dramatic Theatre in Stockholm, Sweden, with Bengt Eklund taking on the role of Erie Smith. This initial staging marked the play's global debut, years after its creation. The first English-language production followed in 1963 at the Theatre Royal, Bath, featuring Burgess Meredith as Erie. These early productions laid the groundwork for the play's eventual recognition and established its presence in the theatrical world, highlighting its unique structure and profound character study.The play made its Broadway debut in 1964, starring Jason Robards as Erie and directed by José Quintero. Robards' performance earned him a Tony Award nomination, solidifying his connection to the role. He later revived the production multiple times, including in Berkeley, California, in 1975 with Jack Dodson as Charlie Hughes. Robards and Dodson continued to perform "Hughie" at the Hyde Park Festival Theatre in 1981 and with the Trinity Repertory Company in Providence, Rhode Island, in 1991. Their performances were also televised for PBS in 1984, bringing the play to a wider audience and further cementing its place in American theater.
Broadway Revivals and Notable Performances
Since its initial 1964 Broadway run, "Hughie" has returned to the Great White Way three additional times, each revival bringing new interpretations and acclaimed performances. In 1975, it was presented in repertory with David Scott Milton's play "Duet," featuring Ben Gazzara as Erie, who also received a Tony Award nomination for his portrayal. This pairing allowed audiences to experience "Hughie" alongside another work, potentially highlighting its unique qualities.The Circle in the Square Theatre staged a production in 1996, directed by and starring Al Pacino. This high-profile revival brought significant attention to the play, with a design team that included David Gallo for sets, Donald Holder for lights, Candice Donnelly for costumes, and John Gromada for sound. More recently, in 2010, the Goodman Theatre in Chicago presented the play with Brian Dennehy in the starring role. This production garnered positive reviews, with particular emphasis on Dennehy's powerful performance. Later that same year, the Long Wharf Theatre in New Haven, Connecticut, also featured Dennehy as Erie, further showcasing his acclaimed interpretation.
Continued Theatrical and Televised Adaptations
The enduring appeal of "Hughie" is evident in its continued revivals and adaptations. In 2013, the Shakespeare Theatre Company in Washington, D.C., brought the play to its stage with Richard Schiff as Erie. The play returned to Broadway for a fourth time in February 2016, starring Forest Whitaker as Erie Smith. This 2016 revival was directed by Michael Grandage, with Darren Bagert serving as a lead producer. Despite the star power, this production had a shortened run of 55 performances, closing on March 27, 2016.Beyond the stage, "Hughie" has also been adapted for television on multiple occasions, demonstrating its international reach and adaptability. In addition to the 1984 PBS broadcast featuring Robards and Dodson, the play was televised in 1959 for Swedish television, in 1960 for Norwegian television, in 1963 for Dutch television, in 1970 for Italian television, and in 1983 for French television. These numerous productions and broadcasts underscore the play's lasting impact and its ability to resonate with diverse audiences across different mediums and cultures, exploring universal themes through its intimate two-character format.
