"We Built This City," the debut single by the American rock band Starship from their 1985 album *Knee Deep in the Hoopla*, achieved significant commercial success upon its release. Written by Bernie Taupin, Martin Page, Dennis Lambert, and Peter Wolf, the song quickly climbed the charts, peaking at No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100. Its popularity extended beyond the United States, topping charts in Australia and Canada, and reaching the Top 10 in Germany,
the Republic of Ireland, Sweden, and Switzerland. Despite this widespread commercial triumph, the song developed a controversial legacy, becoming a frequent target of critical disdain in later decades.
Initially, the song received positive reviews from music publications. *Billboard* in 1985 described it as an "unusual rock 'n' roll anthem" that was both "wise as it is rebellious." *Cash Box* also praised the track, calling it an "ear-catching tune" and characterizing it as "dance rock with sharp hooks." This early reception, coupled with its chart performance, led to a Grammy Award nomination for Best Rock Vocal Performance by a Duo or Group in 1986, solidifying its status as a commercially and critically recognized hit at the time of its release.
Chart Dominance and Global Reach
The commercial impact of "We Built This City" was undeniable. Its ascent to the top of the Billboard Hot 100 marked a significant achievement for Starship. Grace Slick, who shared lead vocals on the track with Mickey Thomas, made history with this song on November 16, 1985, becoming the oldest female vocalist to top the Billboard Hot 100 at that time, shortly after her 46th birthday. This record was later broken by Slick herself with "Nothing's Gonna Stop Us Now" in 1987, and then by Cher in 1999.
Beyond its domestic success, the song demonstrated considerable international appeal. It not only topped the charts in Australia and Canada but also secured positions within the Top 20 in Belgium, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom. Furthermore, it reached the Top 30 in Austria and the Netherlands. This broad international performance underscored the song's widespread popularity and its ability to resonate with audiences across different countries, establishing it as a global hit of the mid-1980s.
The Shifting Tides of Critical Opinion
Despite its initial positive reception and commercial success, the critical perception of "We Built This City" began to sour in the decades following its release. By 2004, *Blender* magazine featured the song at number one on its list of "The 50 Worst Songs Ever," a sentiment echoed by the VH1 Special *The 50 Most Awesomely Bad Songs...Ever*. *Blender* editor Craig Marks noted that the choice was nearly unanimous among those polled, stating that the song "purports to be anti-commercial but reeks of '80s corporate-rock commercialism," and that it was "a real reflection of what practically killed rock music in the '80s."
This negative re-evaluation continued to gain traction. In 2011, a *Rolling Stone* magazine online readers poll named "We Built This City" the worst song of the 1980s, with a winning margin so large that the magazine reported it "could be the biggest blow-out victory in the history of the *Rolling Stone* Readers Poll." By August 2016, *Gentleman's Quarterly* magazine went even further, declaring it the "most detested song in human history." These later assessments stand in stark contrast to the song's initial acclaim and commercial dominance, illustrating a significant shift in its legacy over time.
Defending the "Catchy Pop Song"
Not everyone agreed with the harsh critical assessments. Melissa Ruggieri, a music critic for the *Richmond Times-Dispatch*, found the song's placement at the top of *Blender*'s list "ridiculous." She highlighted elements like its reference to Marconi, the inclusion of DJ chatter from San Francisco, and Grace Slick's delivery of the phrase "corporation games" as reasons to appreciate the track. Ruggieri argued that "part of being cool is admitting to finding the value in catchy pop songs."
Les Garland, the MTV executive and former DJ who provided the voiceover in the song's bridge, also dismissed the *Blender* list as "a joke," comparing the song's ranking to "like saying Coca-Cola is the worst drink ever." Starship singer Mickey Thomas expressed surprise at the ranking but also a sense of being "thrilled" to be listed alongside other high-profile groups. He later noted that *Blender* had folded while Starship remained, suggesting a resilience that outlasted its critics. These defenses underscore the subjective nature of musical taste and the enduring appeal that "We Built This City" held for some, despite its widespread critical condemnation.













