The Buffalo Bills, as a charter member of the American Football League (AFL), embarked on their professional football journey in 1960. A critical step in establishing their team was participation in the inaugural 1960 AFL draft, which aimed to stock the newly formed league's franchises with players. This draft, conducted in late 1959, was a foundational event for the Bills, as it provided the initial talent pool from which their first roster would
be built. The team adopted its name after a public contest, choosing the same moniker as the former All-America Football Conference (AAFC) team in Buffalo, linking their new identity to local football history.
The Draft Structure for the Bills
The 1960 AFL draft for the Buffalo Bills, like other teams, was structured into distinct rounds. The primary draft event featured two main phases: the "First Selections" and the "Second Selections." These rounds were crucial for the Bills to acquire players who would form the core of their inaugural squad. The overall draft process was comprehensive, lasting 33 rounds in total, with an additional 20-round draft held later in December 1959. This extensive drafting period underscored the league's commitment to ensuring each team had ample opportunity to build a competitive roster from scratch.
Teams were required to fill specific positional needs with their initial picks. For their first 11 selections, teams, including the Bills, had to choose four backs, two ends, two tackles, two guards, and one center. This rule was designed to ensure a balanced foundation for each team's roster. The selection order for each position was determined by drawing lots before the picks were made, aiming for fairness in the distribution of early talent. This structured approach was vital for the Bills as they sought to establish their identity and competitiveness in the nascent league.
The Bills' Inaugural Season Context
Following the draft, the Buffalo Bills began their first season in the AFL with Buster Ramsey as their head coach. The team played its home games at War Memorial Stadium in Buffalo, New York. In their inaugural year, the Bills compiled a record of 5 wins, 8 losses, and 1 tie, placing them third in the AFL Eastern Division. This initial performance reflected the challenges and opportunities of building a team from the ground up, relying on the talent acquired through the draft.
Notably, the Bills' early focus was on defense, a contrast to the more offensive-minded trend in the AFL at the time. Their defense allowed the third-fewest points in the league (303) and led the league in fewest passing yards allowed (2,130) and most passes intercepted (33). While their offense struggled, particularly with passing, the draft did bring in players like running back Wray Carlton and flanker Elbert Dubenion, who would later become AFL All-Stars for the Bills. The 1960 draft was thus a critical first step in shaping the Buffalo Bills franchise, laying the groundwork for both immediate performance and future success.













