The Core Allegations
The controversy erupted after renowned author Perumal Murugan raised concerns about questionable books at the newly inaugurated Periyar Arivulagam library in Coimbatore. The allegations claim that a large number of books, possibly over 1,800 titles, supplied
by a few publishers appear to be fake, plagiarised, or generated by Artificial Intelligence. These books are accused of having false authors, incorrect factual information, suspect ISBNs (International Standard Book Numbers), and being sold at unusually high prices. The issue has since expanded, with similar books found in other major institutions like the Connemara Public Library and the Kalaignar Centenary Library. The court has noted that this raises serious questions about the use of public funds and breaches the public's right to access quality information.
The Court Steps In
Taking serious note of the issue, the Madurai bench of the Madras High Court intervened while hearing a contempt petition regarding the non-compliance of its earlier directions on transparent book procurement. A bench of Justices G.R. Swaminathan and M.D. Sumathi ordered the state's Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption (DVAC) to register a First Information Report (FIR) and launch an investigation into the matter. The court also ordered the immediate freezing of the bank accounts belonging to the primary publisher in question, Agal Vilakku Publication, and its proprietor. It has directed that the suspect books be removed from library shelves and that disciplinary action be taken against any officials found to be involved in the procurement irregularities.
Fake Authors and False Content
Specific examples highlighted in court underscore the gravity of the allegations. One book titled 'Democracy and People's Right in the Contemporary World' was falsely attributed to the noted economist Jean Drèze, who has publicly denounced the book as a fake. The court also expressed dismay that works were being falsely credited to the celebrated Tamil poet Subramania Bharati, stating that the poet could only 'turn in his grave'. In another instance, a book incorrectly identifies 'Naladiyar' as a single poet when it is actually a classical Tamil anthology of 400 verses. These examples point to a systemic failure in vetting and quality control, allowing books with dubious content and phantom authors to enter the public library system.
A Modern Legal and Ethical Dilemma
The court has framed this issue as a potential violation of the public's constitutional right to receive accurate information under Article 19(1)(a). The judges noted that books that are AI-generated, plagiarised, or contain false narratives would fall under the category of 'doubtful taste' as per the Tamil Nadu Public Libraries Rules, 1950, and should not be procured with public funds. The case has ignited a debate on the role of AI in publishing and the need for robust verification mechanisms in public procurement. While it has not been definitively proven that AI was used to generate the books, the scandal highlights how easily such content could potentially slip through institutional checks, posing a significant challenge to authenticity and accountability.
What Happens Next?
The DVAC has been granted time to register the FIR and proceed with its investigation, which includes examining key witnesses like author Perumal Murugan. The court has been firm in its stance that a fraud of this magnitude could not have occurred without the involvement of public servants and has demanded that the Director of Public Libraries submit a list of all officials involved in the procurement process. The court has also suggested that for full transparency, the government should consider publishing a comprehensive list of all books procured for public libraries over the last two decades. The outcome of this case could set a crucial precedent for how public institutions across India handle content verification in the age of generative AI.
















