An Author Raises the Alarm
The issue exploded into public view when acclaimed Tamil novelist Perumal Murugan visited the newly inaugurated Periyar Arivulagam library in Coimbatore. In an article published in early November 2026, he detailed his disturbing findings: nearly 1,800
books in the Tamil section seemed suspicious. These books, mostly from a little-known publisher called Agal Vilakku Pathippagam, featured unfamiliar authors, questionable ISBNs, glaring factual errors, and unusually high prices. For instance, one book incorrectly described 'Naladiyar,' a classical collection of verses, as a single poet and was priced at a steep 1,445 rupees. Another book falsely attributed authorship to renowned economist Jean Drèze, who later publicly confirmed he did not write it.
The Court's Stern Intervention
Following the public outcry, the Madras High Court stepped in decisively on November 10, 2026. Hearing a contempt petition related to a 2024 order on transparent book procurement, a bench directed the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption (DVAC) to register a First Information Report (FIR) and launch a criminal investigation into what it termed a large-scale scam. The court also ordered the freezing of bank accounts belonging to the implicated publishers and called for immediate disciplinary action, including suspension, against the public officials involved. The judges noted that the procurement of bogus books using public funds infringes upon the public's right to receive accurate information under the Constitution.
The Specter of 'Algorithmic Authors'
While it has not yet been definitively proven that the books were created by artificial intelligence, the term 'AI-generated' has become central to the controversy. Tamil Nadu's School Education Minister, A. Rajmohan, has called the situation potentially 'India's first AI scam'. The suspicion arises from the combination of fabricated author names, seemingly compiled online content, and a lack of editorial oversight. AI tools can produce superficially credible manuscripts complete with plausible structures and covers, making them difficult to flag in procurement processes that aren't rigorous. The court observed that such AI-generated and plagiarised works could be classified under 'doubtful taste' according to the Tamil Nadu Public Libraries Rules, 1950, and should not have been purchased.
Broader Implications and What's Next
This case has cast a spotlight on the vulnerabilities in public procurement systems in an era of rapidly advancing technology. The investigation is expanding beyond the single library in Coimbatore, with officials already removing hundreds of suspect books from other institutions, including the historic Connemara Public Library in Chennai. More than 160 writers and publishers have now called for an independent inquiry and a full audit of library collections across the state. The scandal has also triggered a political blame game, with the current government pointing fingers at the previous administration for the procurement orders. Ultimately, this probe is about more than just questionable books; it's a test case for how public institutions will safeguard quality, authenticity, and accountability against a new wave of digital and AI-driven fraud.
















