What is the ‘AI Library’ Case?
The controversy centres on the procurement of hundreds of questionable books for public libraries in Tamil Nadu, including the newly opened Periyar Arivulagam Library in Coimbatore. The issue gained significant attention after renowned Tamil novelist
Perumal Murugan raised concerns about the collection, pointing to books with unfamiliar authors, inflated prices, and suspicious ISBN numbers from a little-known publisher, Agal Vilakku Pathippagam. The allegations suggest a large-scale fraud where public funds were used to purchase substandard, fake, and possibly AI-generated content. The Madras High Court has taken serious notice, ordering the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption (DVAC) to register an FIR and investigate the matter, calling it a potential 'fraud of humongous proportion'.
AI Authors and Phantom Credits
The core allegations are twofold: the books contain fabricated information and are attributed to phantom authors. For example, a book was found that incorrectly named a collection of ancient verses as a single poet. Another work was falsely attributed to the respected economist Jean Drèze, who publicly denounced the book as a fake. Similarly, unauthentic stories were added under the name of the celebrated poet Subramania Bharati. While the term 'AI-generated' is being used, it's not yet definitively proven that artificial intelligence wrote these books from scratch. The more immediate issue is the blatant falsehood in content and authorship, which the court noted violates the public's right to receive accurate information under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution.
The Court Steps In
Acting on a contempt petition regarding its own 2024 directions on transparent book procurement, the Madurai bench of the Madras High Court issued a series of strong orders on November 10, 2026. The court directed the DVAC to register an FIR, ordered the freezing of bank accounts linked to the publisher Agal Vilakku, and called for disciplinary action, including suspension, against the officials involved. Five senior library officials have since been suspended. The court stated that stocking public libraries with 'bogus books with false content' breaches the Tamil Nadu Public Libraries Act, 1948. It also held that AI-generated and plagiarised works would fall under the category of books with 'doubtful taste', which are barred from procurement under library rules.
Can AI-Generated Work Be Copyrighted?
This case highlights a global legal grey area. In India, the Copyright Act, 1957 does not recognise a non-human entity like an AI as an author. Copyright protection is contingent on human creativity. However, a provision in the Act does recognise the 'person who causes the work to be created' using a computer as its author. This raises complex questions: Is the 'author' the person who writes the AI prompt, the developer who created the AI, or someone else? Indian courts have not yet settled this issue, though a case involving news agency ANI and OpenAI is pending in the Delhi High Court. For now, the consensus is that a work requires significant human input and originality to be copyrightable.
Why This Case Matters for India
Described by Tamil Nadu's Education Minister as potentially 'India's first AI scam', this case is a watershed moment. It goes beyond just one state, exposing how easily new technologies can be used to exploit gaps in public procurement and accountability. The scandal has prompted over 160 writers and artists to demand an independent inquiry and a statewide audit of library collections. The court's firm stance and the ongoing DVAC investigation will likely set a crucial precedent for how India's legal and administrative systems handle issues of intellectual property, authenticity, and fraud in the rapidly expanding age of artificial intelligence. It serves as a stark reminder that while technology advances, the need for human vigilance and integrity remains paramount.
















