Just a few years ago, Paul Pogba was on top of the world. A World Cup winner with France and the planet's most expensive player, he was a force of nature. So how did it all unravel into a story of injuries, controversy, and a doping ban?
The Impossible Weight of a Record Fee
When Paul Pogba
returned to Manchester United in 2016 for a then-world record fee of £89 million, it was framed as a homecoming for a superstar. The club had let him leave for Juventus for free four years earlier, and his return was a statement. But the price tag became a curse. Every pass, every haircut, and every social media post was scrutinised through the lens of that massive fee. Pogba was expected not just to play well, but to single-handedly elevate a team struggling to find its identity after Sir Alex Ferguson's retirement. The pressure was immense, and from the start, there were debates about his best role. Was he a defensive anchor or a creative force? The lack of a clear answer would haunt his entire second spell at the club.
A Midfielder Without a Position
At Juventus, Pogba thrived on the left of a midfield three, a role that gave him the freedom to showcase his unique blend of power, skill, and vision. He was a marauding force, equally capable of a crunching tackle and a long-range screamer. At Manchester United, he rarely found such a perfect fit. He was often deployed in a deeper two-man midfield, which curbed his attacking instincts and exposed his defensive vulnerabilities. Managers from José Mourinho to Ole Gunnar Solskjær struggled to build a system that consistently unlocked his genius. The result was a player who could produce moments of breathtaking quality one week, only to look lost and ineffective the next. This inconsistency frustrated fans and pundits, who felt his extraordinary talent was being wasted.
The Body Began to Fail
As the years at Old Trafford went on, another problem became impossible to ignore: injuries. A series of ankle, thigh, and hamstring problems repeatedly broke his momentum. From the summer of 2019 onwards, he started a strikingly low number of league games. Each comeback felt like a fresh start that was cruelly cut short. This physical fragility followed him back to Juventus, where he moved on a free transfer in 2022, hoping to recapture his old magic. Almost immediately, he suffered a serious knee injury that required surgery and forced him to miss the 2022 World Cup. His first season back in Italy was a near total write-off, with just a handful of appearances.
Off-Pitch Turmoil and Distractions
While his body was failing him, his life off the pitch was also in turmoil. In 2022, it was revealed that he was the target of an alleged extortion plot involving childhood friends and even his own brother, Mathias. The saga included accusations of witchcraft aimed at his France teammate Kylian Mbappé, claims Pogba strongly denied. He later spoke of the mental toll, admitting there were times he no longer wanted to play football at all. Alongside this, his high-profile persona, fueled by his agent and a documentary series, sometimes created a perception of a player more focused on his brand than his team, a criticism that dogged him throughout his time in Manchester.
The Final Blow: A Doping Ban
The final, and most devastating, chapter of his derailment came in August 2023. After being an unused substitute for Juventus, he was randomly selected for a doping test. He tested positive for DHEA, a substance that can boost testosterone. Despite his claims that he had taken a supplement unknowingly, he was handed a four-year ban from the sport in February 2024. The Court of Arbitration for Sport later reduced the ban to 18 months on appeal, meaning he could return in March 2025. But the damage was done. Juventus terminated his contract, and a player once destined for the Ballon d'Or found his career in ruins.
















