The Spark of the Controversy
The issue gained public attention after renowned Tamil novelist Perumal Murugan raised alarms about the collection at the newly inaugurated Periyar Arivulagam library in Coimbatore. In an online article, he described finding nearly 1,800 books from a little-known
publisher, Agal Vilakku Pathippagam, that were riddled with problems. These included unfamiliar author names, unusually high prices, factual errors, and questionable International Standard Book Numbers (ISBNs). For example, one book incorrectly described 'Naladiyar', a classic collection of 400 verses, as a single poet. Another falsely attributed authorship of a classic poem. This discovery at a major new library, built at a cost of around ₹300 crore, quickly escalated into a significant scandal.
Allegations of 'AI Scam' and Phantom Authors
The concerns go beyond simple errors. The books are suspected of being plagiarised, of poor quality, or even generated by Artificial Intelligence without any real authorship or editorial oversight. One book in another library was attributed to the famed economist Jean Drèze, who publicly stated he never wrote it. This has led Tamil Nadu's School Education Minister, A Rajmohan, to describe the situation as potentially 'India's first AI scam'. The core allegation is that public money was spent on worthless content. The court noted that stocking libraries with bogus books by 'phantom authors' infringes upon the public's right to receive accurate information, a right protected under the Constitution.
The High Court Steps In
The matter reached the Madurai bench of the Madras High Court through a contempt petition. The petition alleged that the procurement violated a 2024 court order that had established a 'Transparent Book Procurement Policy' to prevent precisely these kinds of irregularities. Taking serious note of the issue, a bench of Justices G.R. Swaminathan and M.D. Sumathi observed that a fraud of this scale, involving crores of rupees, could not have happened without the involvement of government officials. The court has since ordered the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption (DVAC) to register a First Information Report (FIR) and launch a full investigation.
Accountability and Public Funds
The court has taken several immediate steps to halt the damage and ensure accountability. It ordered the freezing of bank accounts linked to the primary publisher, Agal Vilakku Pathippagam, and others allegedly involved in the scheme. It also directed the government to take disciplinary action, including suspension, against the officials responsible for the procurement process. Furthermore, librarians across the state have been instructed to identify and remove all the suspect books from circulation to prevent the public from accessing them. The court emphasised that public funds cannot be used to purchase books of 'doubtful taste', a category it stated includes plagiarised or AI-generated works with no verifiable authenticity.
A Systemic Failure and Political Fallout
More than 160 writers, artists, and publishers have issued a joint statement demanding an independent inquiry and a full audit of library collections across Tamil Nadu. They question how such titles could have passed through a multi-layered review process involving expert committees and price negotiations. The scandal has also ignited a political blame game, with the current state government accusing the previous administration of irregularities during the procurement process, a charge the opposition denies. The court itself noted with dismay that while governments change, the problems persist, remarking wryly, 'Actors change, actions do not'. So far, tens of thousands of books have been removed from libraries across the state pending the outcome of the investigation.
















